The Relentless Power of Demography

By Alan Caruba

The Relentless Power of Demography
The Relentless Power of Demography
Alan Caruba
Column by Alan Caruba

Manasquan, NJ –-( The President of the United States is routinely referred to as the most powerful man on the Earth.

There is a greater power and it is the changing characteristics of population, something that occurs constantly here and around the world.

Laws are powerless against it and, in particular, laws that were passed some eighty to fifty years ago with the best of intentions. I refer, in particular, to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. No one anticipated that Americans would routinely live to their current life expectancy of 78 years, nor that advances in medicine and healthcare would extend their lives into their late 80’s and their 90’s.

Nor could laws anticipate American lifestyles that went from a time when older citizens often lived with and were cared for by their children to a time when retirement communities exist along with facilities that provide care for the elderly afflicted with the illness associated with aging such as the explosion of Alzheimer’s disease. In the 1930s, no one anticipated the emancipation of women and their empowerment in the workplace.

Jonathan Last is a senior writer at the Weekly Standard and the author of a new book, “What to Expect When No One’s Expecting: American’s Coming Demographic Disaster.” The Wall Street Journal recently published an article by Last, “America’s Baby Bust.”

Demographics, birth rates, aging, and the movement of populations such as the many Hispanics that crossed our southern border to seek jobs and enjoy the benefits America extends through programs that aid the poor. For the second time since 1986, Congress is attempting to grapple with millions of illegal aliens and their children who call America home.

While the immigration debate rages, Last notes that it has been the immigration of Hispanics that has kept the U.S. from becoming as stagnant as Japan. “While the nation as a whole has a fertility rate of 1.93, the Hispanic-American fertility rate is 2.35.” Even that is beginning to decline.

“Forget the debt ceiling, Forget the fiscal cliff, the sequestration cliff and the entitlement cliff. These are just symptoms. What America really faces is a demographic cliff: The root cause of most of our problems is our declining fertility rate.”

“The fertility rate is the number of children an average woman bears over the course of her life. The replacement rate is 2.1. If the average woman has more children than that, the population grows. Fewer, and it contracts. Today, America’s total fertility rate is 1.93, according to the latest figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; it hasn’t been above the replacement rate in a sustained way since the early 1970s.”

The only blip in our fertility rate followed the end of WWII and that cohort became known as the “baby boomers.” They are now retiring in large numbers daily. That is putting a strain on the Social Security and Medicare programs.

In the “good old days” women were, for the most part, homemakers caring for their families, but not part of the job market. Another factor after WWII was the belief that everyone had to have a college degree to have upward mobility. “Women,” notes Last, “began attending college in equal (and then ever greater) numbers than men.”

This caused young people of both sexes to put off marriage and, as the economy encountered recessions and the present fiscal uncertainties, the cost of college has skyrocketed, and graduation now means a huge debt for many of them before they even enter the job market.

The decrease in the fertility rate is not just an American problem. It is global and we are seeing this in Europe where socialism has been practiced even more briskly than here. As Last points out, “97% of the world’s population now lives in countries where the fertility rate is falling.” It translates into lost productivity and pressures on governments that attempt to prop up and maintain their economies through excessive borrowing. The U.S. government borrows about 40 cents of every dollar it spends.

So the President and Congress face the problem of an aging population, too few new babies being born, and economic policies —increased taxation— that work against the decision to have children. Children are expensive. The “perverse effect of putting government in the business of eldercare has been to reduce the incentives to have children…”

To that we can add putting government in charge of healthcare, education, housing, and energy. It has a track record of ruining these sectors that would thrive if they were returned to the free and open marketplace. One can search the Constitution long and hard to find a justification for government intervention or control and plenty of history to demonstrate they do better when addressed at the state and local level.

“In the face of this decline,” says Last, “the only thing that will preserve America’s place in the world is if all Americans —Democrats, Republicans, Hispanics, blacks, Jews, Christians and atheists— decide to have babies.”

c Alan Caruba

Alan Caruba’s commentaries are posted daily at “Warning Signs” his popular blog and thereafter on dozens of other websites and blogs. If you love to read, visit his monthly report on new books at Bookviews.

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Malthus was wrong 200 years ago and the Paul Ehrlichs of this day are proving to be wrong as well. So badly in fact that Ehrlich’s predictions, such as the 100s of millions that he predicted would starve to death in the 1970s, are now little more than a sad joke about the predictive power of the social sciences In spite of the experts in the field of doom and gloom, for approximately 6 of the worlds 7 billion people things have never been better. That is a fact and an open minded objective study of the issue will show… Read more »

Bill Baker

@Mike the Limey: I’m routing for a zombie apocalypse, all the benefits you suggested plus some of us get a prime excuse to shoot the assholes in our area.

Mike the Limey

There’s already too high a burden of humanity on this mudball.
If we as a species don’t work to reduce our numbers, then nature certainly will.
We’re about out of effective treatment for TB & our arsenal of antibiotics is running low on alternative treatments where bacterial resistance is ever growing.
One major ‘flu pandemic might be the start & we’re well overdue a lethal strain such as that seen in 1919 – 1021.


Our problem isn’t not enough people. We already have too many people. We are going to run out of jobs and resources. The solution is not to pump out more babies that we can’t support. We need to reduce the population.


This man speaks of a dying demographic. Get real. Our children will not live as long as we. Our grand children even less. Why? Because of the poisons in our food created through GMO’s. Our medical care system routinely poisons children in the name of vaccinations. Look at the facts, some 80% of MMR vaccinations are ineffective and laced with toxins. 97% of people getting the flu this year had the flu shot. How about the Baxter Plague? Every phone call to the VA hammers me with a message of how important it is to get the flu shot. I… Read more »


Mr. Caruba.

Thanks for the interesting and thoughtful article. I will soon order Mr. Last’s book.