No Evidence To Support Lead Shot Ban, Just Bad Research

Bogus Research
No Evidence To Support Lead Shot Ban, Just Bad Research
Countryside Alliance Ireland
Countryside Alliance Ireland

Ireland – -(Ammoland.com)- On Wednesday the ‘Oxford Lead Symposium’ published a report of its proceedings from last year.

We were well aware of the contents because the research has all been dealt with repeatedly during the Lead Ammunition Group process.

The BBC, however, was persuaded that there was something worthy of reporting and lead with the claim that “about a 100,000 wetland birds are killed every year” by lead shot.

This headline comes from an estimate of 50,000 – 100,000 wildfowl dying each year as a result of lead poisoning included in a paper produced by RSPB & Wildfowl and Wetland Trust scientists.

This in turn relies mainly on research carried out between 1960 and 1983, all of which occurred before the current restrictions on using lead shot were introduced in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.

The figures therefore provide no real evidence of the current situation and merely illustrate exactly the concerns that the current restrictions on lead shot were brought in to address.

In addition nearly all the wildfowl species referenced in this report are migratory and there is no way of knowing in which country any lead shot that was present in their digestive systems was picked up. Meanwhile, Defra has published bird population statistics which show the majority of wintering wildfowl on the rise in the UK, much to the credit of the fabulous work being done by conservationists, including hundreds of wildfowling clubs and private landowners around the coast.

The Alliance is clear that there does need to be total compliance with lead ammunition restrictions in the UK, and from all signatory parties to the AEWA Agreement which committed other countries to prohibit the use of lead ammunition over wetlands.

The only thing that is clear from the Oxford Lead Symposium, however, is that there remains no case for a total ban based on evidence gathered before the current restrictions were put in place.

Tim Bonner
Chief Executive
Follow on Twitter @CA_TimB

About
Countryside Alliance Ireland has been active since the early 1960s, providing Irish sportsmen and women with high levels of information and advice and representation. Over the years as the political environment has changed we have evolved into a highly effective campaigning organisation. Countryside Alliance Ireland is governed by an elected “Board” made up from members throughout Ireland. The Board sets policy and oversees financial and operational matters. Countryside Alliance Ireland partner groups nominate members of the “Board” also, making it truly representative of country sports interests in Ireland. Visit: www.countrysideallianceireland.org

2 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Grey Beard
Grey Beard
6 years ago

The original “research” done to support the ban on lead shot for waterfowl was fatally flawed from the start. Total Crap Faux results from Total Crap Faux made up “facts” by dishonest liberal hacks. But the msm – aka Lame Stream Media – ate it up and so another nail in OUR coffin.

Yep, whenever some liberal offers “research” we MUST drill down all the way to the bottom and work back up, refuting each step and shouting OUR results from the rooftops.

Maybe some day!

Gregory Romeu
Gregory Romeu
6 years ago

WHEN is society going to realize that whenever ANY, “research” is offered to the public that it MUST BE SCRUTINIZED, Checked, Double-Checked and even Triple-Checked, especially if it is coming from a Liberal?