Crazy Things Pacifists Tell Me About Guns

By Rob Morse

Shocked Scared Man
Crazy Things Pacifists Tell Me About Guns
Slow Facts
Slow Facts

Louisiana- (Ammoland.com)-  I don’t mention being a gun owner to strangers.  Sometimes people find out, and the way they respond is remarkable.  I assume that they are sincere in what they say, but that assumption isn't easy.

Their comments are more of a confession about themselves than an honest question about me.  I usually bite my tongue because of the social situation.  Then it occurred to me that other gun owners must be hearing similar comments.

I’ve kept my answers to myself, but now I’ll share them with you.

“I live on the safe side of town so I don’t need a gun for protection.”

I usually hear this from a well-to-do woman and it makes me smile.  Does she think criminals don’t have maps that show them where the rich people live?  Maybe she thinks criminals can’t drive.  The woman is obviously intelligent, but has a profound blind-spot when it comes to personal safety.  We didn’t meet inside her gated community, so why does she think she is safe everywhere?

“Guns aren’t the answer.”

Maybe guns are not the answer, but then we are certainly talking about different questions.  I assume the speaker knows that the police have firearms for personal protection.  The first person who told me to go armed was a police officer.  I listen to professionals.

“People don’t protect themselves with guns any longer.  That is just a fantasy from the old-west.”

This one perplexes me.  I assume they read too many cowboy novels but they stopped reading too soon.  They never learned the real history of our western frontier.  Also, the speaker never bothered to learn the facts about armed citizens who carry in public now.  Armed towns on the western frontier were safer than our large democrat-controlled cities today.  Ain’t that right, Marshal Dillon?

“Only the police should have guns.”

True, the police should have guns, but have you thought about what it is like to be a policeman?  Almost every policeman I’ve met told me to carry because of what they see every day.  Time after time, day after day, the police arrive too late.  They take reports from innocent injured victims.  That is a core part of their job and it has to hurt.  The police would much rather take your report that says you protected yourself and the criminal ran away.

“Only criminals have guns.”

This is really a statement about how narrow a group of friends the speaker has.  I’m probably the first gun owner they know… and there are a hundred million gun owners in the US.  To be fair, they probably don’t know anyone who owns a pickup truck either.

“You don’t need a gun.”

That is true.  I don’t.  I guess I don’t need toothpaste and deodorant.  I don’t need a fire extinguisher at home or a first aid kit in my car, but I have them..just like I have a firearm.

“My husband or wife has a gun, so I don’t need one.”

This comment makes me bite my tongue.  I’m thinking they volunteered to be the designated victim..or maybe the designated hostage.  Must be an interesting personal relationship they have with their spouse, but I don’t ask.

“Gun’s don’t belong in schools.”

Lots of things don’t belong in schools, but I’ve seen them.  Cuts and broken bones don’t belong in schools, but we have first aid kits on scene for a reason.  I won’t pretend that bad things don’t happen.  I won’t lie to make you feel better.  What exactly is your plan when you see more things you don’t want in schools?

“You just want to kill someone.”

This person obviously has no idea about the costs of threatening to use lethal force, let alone pulling the trigger.  Ignorance must be bliss.

“I couldn’t kill someone.

That is hard to believe.  Maybe the people who say this think they are gentle.  Would they really stand by and watch while their family is threatened or injured?  If I take them seriously, then either they don’t care about other people, or they look forward to seeing an innocent person hurt.   Has some village lost its sociopath?

“People like you shouldn’t have machine guns.”

I’ve fired a machine gun.  Not having automatic weapons hasn’t compromised my self-defense plans since I don’t feel the need to fight off a zombie horde tonight.

“Why do you want another tool that kills?”

I love this question.  I look around the room and see how many things I could use or improvise.  What can I say.  I’m an engineer so everything is a tool.

“You’re more likely to be hurt if you have a gun because the criminal will take your gun away from you.”

So you’re saying we’d be safer if we disarmed the police and gave guns to criminals?   That way the police would always have a gun when they needed it by taking the criminal’s gun!  It’s an interesting idea, but you go first and I’ll record the results from here.

I know I’m not alone.  You’ve heard similar things and you’ve thought similar things.  Thank you for sharing them.. here, and not saying them in public

~_~_

The original article is here.  Rob Morse writes about gun rights at Ammoland, at Clash Daily and on his SlowFacts blog. He hosts the Self Defense Gun Stories Podcast and co-hosts the Polite Society Podcast. Rob is an NRA pistol instructor and combat handgun competitor.

176
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
36 Comment threads
140 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
68 Comment authors
AlanHeed the Call-upCrotalus MaxximusWild BillDonald Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Alan
Guest
Alan

By the way, re the line of rubbish peddeled by the anti gunners and their fellow travelers, think they actually believe the rubbish they peddle?

Alan
Guest
Alan

The arrogant ignorance, stupidity if you prefer, of some segments of the population is truly amazing, I reference anti gun types, notwithstanding that people have the right to disarm themselves if they so choose. Strikes me however that many of the anti’s are the sort of persons who having gone out in the rain, without suitable cover, simply cannot understand how it came to be that they got wet.

Donald
Guest
Donald

When I opened my safe and showed my Mother In Law my guns she ran out of the room screaming even though all of them were unloaded. Talk about a manufactured fear of guns.

Alan
Guest
Alan

What does her daughter say, how does she act or react?

Jim Macklin
Guest
Jim Macklin

President Trump has a NYC carry permit. But he doesn’t need a gun because he has at least 100 Secret Service agents armed with Uzis, Glocks, M4s and they can carry anywhere on the planet Earth.

Mr. Ree
Guest
Mr. Ree

One should not be too quick to dismiss the “pacifist’s” argument, “I couldn’t kill someone.” He/she may very well be correct. Suggest you read Lt. Col. Dave Grossman’s book “On Killing” before too quickly attacking this post.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Mr. Ree, that isn’t the same as being a pacifist, but I understand your point. Although, self-defense is *not* about killing someone, it’s stopping the threat. The threat may expire, but that isn’t the intent. The studies of soldiers shooting their firearms in battle is interesting. It is also interesting that, in recognizing that deficiency, the military has been able to alter their training so that more soldiers are willing to shoot when necessary. I, being very non-violent, had to mentally come to terms with that when I decided to carry. A relative who is now a retired LEO, during… Read more »

Mr. Ree
Guest
Mr. Ree

I do not disagree with your point, because it reinforces mine. Humans are not predisposed to kill other humans (i.e.“I couldn’t kill someone.”) Grossman’s research confirmed that for most folks, killing another human is not natural, and humans usually must be conditioned to do so. So if someone says, “I couldn’t kill someone,” I submit the correct response is, “Your’e right, you probably can’t. But you can learn to do so in those instances where you may be call upon to use deadly force to protect yourself or a loved one. And that is something you have an obligation to… Read more »

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Slightly off the original topic but certainly something that bears thinking about. One of the worst examples of conditioning to kill are the child soldiers. If ever there was a reason for summary execution it would be for those who indoctrinate and teach children to kill. I was speaking of killing and death to my former partner last night, remembering the first person I ever saw shot, many many years ago. It’s not like the movies, there was no great pool of blood. In fact, in this case there was no exit wound and I was amazed that a very… Read more »

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Mr. Ree, I agree with everything you stated. I have read a lot on these topics and thought greatly about it because I do not believe in violence or hurting anything – that is why I was never interested in hunting, even though I was a very good shot. I am older now, and I have come to accept certain things about life that are non-negotiable. Yes, avoiding the situation all together is always the best solution when possible. That is what is taught in self-defense and in situational awareness. And I understand your point about having seen enough hurt… Read more »

Donald
Guest
Donald

You don’t have to kill anyone, shoot’em in the leg.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Donald, the idea of self-defense is not to kill. Stopping the threat may result in that, but it isn’t the intent. Even one punch can kill, and that has been in the news several times recently. Even stun guns and pepper spray are called less lethal, not non-lethal. Almost anything that you do to defend yourself has lethal potential. One needs to be willing to protect oneself and family knowing that injury or death may result, and it might be one’s own self that endures that result. That is why avoiding the conflict to begin with is always the wiser,… Read more »

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Donald, Yes, shoot them in the leg with MLRS.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

WB, but only from a safe distance.

CJ
Guest
CJ

The question I got; Why do you need a gun? My answer? Because of people like you. When he gave me a shocked “what do you mean?” I just dismissively waved him off and got back to work. It bothered him the rest of the week and he would try to get me to explain it to him at every turn. Finally on Friday he cornered me in the break room and demanded an explanation. Since I’m a good bit older than he is, I just gave him that grandfatherly smile you give a petulant child and patted him on… Read more »

JJ
Guest
JJ

I don’t suffer idiots, morons, or liberals well, I tend to refute their bad logic or just call them a dumb a** and move on. That tends to really piss one of my sisters off, even after I tell her I love you anyway.

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@JJ, Neather do we, Are you ever going to have fun here! Welcome aboard, JJ!

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Hey Bill, this one is certainly running around the block and back. I was trying to figure out a way to get an email address to you without the “Gil’s” of the world getting it also but haven’t come up with a way yet.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Vanns40, create a temporary email account, after he replies to you, close the account and use your regular one.

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Ya just never know who’s gonna reply with a false name. I did think about that and may try the throw away route.

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Vanns, I did not see this until just now. I may have a local business that would receive a snail mail letter on my behalf. You send me a email address in the hard copy letter. I email you. I don’t think any modern person would be interested in going to all that work, expense, and old technology to get a hold of one email address. What are your thoughts?

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40
Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

The email I just listed is a throw away.

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Throwrainwateratgmail.com

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Vanns, attempted to send email. Message: address rejected or not fully qualified. I’ll try again tomorrow.

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Okay, got “Heed the call_up”, sorry, was looking for Bill.

@Wild Bill, it does work. Check and make sure you didn’t have a typo.

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Vanns, Ok, brother, round out!

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

@WildBill

Remember to use @ not “at”

BikerDad
Guest
BikerDad

What? No invocation of Markley’s Law by the “crazy pacifist”? How… out of character.

PastorGlock
Guest
PastorGlock

Ex mother in law came home and found 3 individuals in her home. She lived in “nice and quiet” part of town here in southern comifornia. Luckily for her when she opened the door and made eye contact with them they ran off through back door and did not assault or kill her. When police arrived 15min later one officer asked if she owned a firearm and she replied no. Said officer said she should really consider upgrading home security and purchasing a firearm. He also said if she chose to buy one and was home when being robbed that… Read more »

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

Dead bodies DO tell tales . . . through the interpretation of a forensic pathologist.

However, dead bodies do not get up on the witness stand and perjure themselves as live criminals habitually do.

Gil
Guest
Gil

That’s what I said up above – there are times when it’s no longer sensible to let the other person live because of the legal ramifications.

Pat George
Guest
Pat George

LOVE IT!

Gunwrites
Guest
Gunwrites

My older sister, in disdain, asked, “Why do YOU need more than one gun?” I replied, “Why do YOU need 60 some pairs of shoes?” Another time she asked, “Just how many guns do you own?” I replied, “Why? Would you like to borrow one?”

Eric_CA
Guest
Eric_CA

Ha ha ha. Destined to be a classic reply. “Why do YOU need 60 some pairs of shoes?”

JJ
Guest
JJ

Sisters gotta love em.

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@JJ some … others not so much.

Don Bailey
Guest
Don Bailey

That is in the line of questioning a stamp collector why they would need more than one stamp in the collection. It all comes down to the level of ignorance of the collection.

robert
Guest
robert

Good article, and I agree with everything you say here … except the implication of your title. You’re equating pacifism with anti-gun stance.That’s just silly. I’ve been a lifelong pacifist who happens to love guns, have all kinds of guns, and is not fond of war. Does that last bit make me “anti-gun”? Even as a pacifist, I will fight (and have fought) when called upon to do so. That doesn’t mean I love fighting, or warfare in general. And here’s a newsflash for you: I know of many others like me, many of whom have served and/or continue to… Read more »

Gil
Guest
Gil

Ahem. Pacifism refers to someone who renounces violence even in self-defense. Using violence in the course of self-defense doesn’t requires a special -ism.

Mick
Guest
Mick

Only to an idiot like you Gil !

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, that isn’t necessarily true. One can be against war and violence, but still believe in the right of self-defense. I fit into that category. I will never act violently toward anyone, but I sure as h- will protect my family and myself from anyone attacking them or me.

Gil
Guest
Gil

Nope. Look it up. Simply saying there times when violence is wrong and other times when violence is the correct course of action isn’t pacifism.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, you need to look at the definition of pacifism. One can be a pacifist, but still believe in protecting oneself and family. I don’t believe in outward aggression, meaning I will not be the one becoming violent, but that doesn’t mean I will allow my family or myself to be attacked. Self-defense is not aggression nor violence.

Gil
Guest
Gil

That’s the use of reasonable force in self-defense not pacifism. Rather reasonable force tends to also have a legal definition too.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, correct, self-defense isn’t pacifism, however, one can employ self-dense and still be non-violent and against violence (pacifistic). One does not preclude the other.

Don Bailey
Guest
Don Bailey

@Heed the Call-up, You obviously labored through philosophy 101 and understand the art of reason.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Don Bailey, labored through it? No, but I did read a lot of it when I was a kid. My father had a lot of books on the Ancient Greek philosophers – very interesting reads, but I understand why some believe the material is to “dry”. I also loved Poe. However, I just dabble with sophistry, it’s more fun to use against the Gils of the world, their weak minds can’t grasp logic.

Joel S
Guest
Joel S

(Aussie here) since gun control went nuts in 1996 after the port Arthur massacre (30 odd deaths) only 40 people die a year here in Australia due to illegal firearms.. Its funny though because 1994-5 both only had 38 deaths by gunfire.. however since 96, stabbing and aggravated assult takes 70-100 people in a month… They took our guns and now look at us, we’re a controlled state, you guys n gals hang on to your freedoms, especially your 2nd Amendment. Only our crook cops and crims have guns and we’re all suffering because of it…

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Joel S, Texas is calling!

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@ Wild Bill … Went spelunking back into the dark ages, about two stair passage ways below and behind the wine cellar deep into my archives. There I found an article from Guns& Ammo magazine dated March 1975 By one Bob Steindler titled “Reduced Loads Pros and Cons” . In it he specifically notes a load of IMR 4350 / 45 gr. / 150 gr bullet in a .270. He shows a photo of an arisaka action blown to pieces. To make a long story short, he states another writer named Mattern suggest filling the air space with Corn Meal,… Read more »

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@OV, Wow, ok then! I better bring that experiment to a halt.

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@WB I would that Hodgdon would have an idea to help you. I know they bought up some of the other companies.

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

That kind of blowup is a known phenomenon with reduced charges in artillery . . . it results from the wave fronts colliding after dual ignition.

If the case is reasonably full, the charge can only ignite at one end, but if it’s not full, then the primer flash ignites the powder near the primer and the powder at the front end and the two flame fronts slam together in the middle, with an absolutely insane pressure spike.

Don’t use reduced charges of slow powder . . . always at least a 75% fill.

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@WL Thanks that was my gut feeling when Wild Bill first ask his question. I had remembered reading something on it years ago. I started reloading around 1972 so I had a habit of collecting articles on it . My areas of interests were fairly narrow only four or five calibers or problems. This just happened to be one.

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@WF wouldn’t want to lose Wild Bill

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@OV, Well, thank you, brother. Of course it would not be my first facial scar!

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@WebfL, Are you a Ft. Sill grad?

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

No, I’ve never been to Fort Sill, though that was a possible career path at one point.

I actually ran across the reference to the phenomenon in a book I was reading on artillery development, then to its presence in handloads later.

BTW, that’s closely related to the Munroe Effect, which is how shaped charges work, so it’s seriously bad juju in a rifle’s chamber, especially if the propellant detonates high-order instead of burning in an orderly fashion.

it’s also closely related to a demolition technique used for cutting steel . . .

freewill
Guest
freewill

if im out some where and an attack occures, i might just sit and wait till he comes after me and watch what he does to you 🙂

JustKev
Guest
JustKev

I’ve had a lady tell me she has the right to not be afraid to go out in public so no one should be allowed to carry concealed. It was in the comment section of a local paper. I didn’t tell her that if she’s walked by me in the local grocery store she’s been very close to a concealed firearm. Didn’t want to scare her.

Warlocc
Guest
Warlocc

“I couldn’t kill someone.”

I have no problem with this statement. Just like we don’t think people should force us to be without guns, we shouldn’t force other people to own them that don’t want them.

John Frazer
Guest
John Frazer

What does the need to fight off the inevitable zombie infestation have to do with our ability or any reasonable person’s possible desire to own automatic weapons?

Not right to dismiss wanting such things with the slur and hyperbole.

Somebody really needs to take US v Miller to task. It established that only weapons suitable for real military use are protected, and they mistakenly said short shotguns had no military history or utility. By that, we damn well should have anything an infantry unit might deploy with.

Markarov
Guest
Markarov

A few weeks after moving into their new home, my sister-in-law pulled me aside when she noticed me ‘printing’. Her explanation was they didn’t want a gun in the house, I didn’t need one; because nothing was going to happen there, they lived in a safe area.
I went out to my car, transferred my gun in my pocket, and walked back in; she was none the wiser. I then asked her if she would like me to get rid of their fire extinguishers…
My brother had burned their last house to the ground… And they had three unused fire extinguishers…

Brian Robertson
Guest
Brian Robertson

My favorite comment from a liberal about owning guns was that he was afraid to own them, because he knew that he would get angry and kill someone. He asked me how I didn’t kill people? I told him that I don’t draw a gun in anger.

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

As far as I can tell that’s the real issue with a lot of antigun people: their own lack of control frightens them, and they believe that everybody is just like they are, so nobody can be trusted with a gun.

A minority has simply been brainwashed.

Gil
Guest
Gil

Rather no one has made you angry enough . . . yet.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, self-defense isn’t about anger. It’s astounding how you ignore reality. Nowhere has anyone, nor any of these stories, ever suggested acting in anger.

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

If they haven’t done it in thirty years they aren’t going to.

Not even the whacko screaming death threats at me for daring to drive down the street in front of her, nor the one screamign death threats at me for NOT blindly running a red light. ( saw him in action a number of times and was sure we were going to be seeing him in the headlines for his constant roadrage.)

Project much?

Trolling Thunder
Guest
Trolling Thunder

Gil, I have been carrying concealed for over 15 years now and I have been in situations that had me absolutely enraged a few times while being armed. The difference between you and I is that I have self control, and even though I may be angry enough to consider smacking someone in the mouth, I have enough self awareness to realize that escalating a situation while I am armed could result in life changing (or life ending) consequences. If you truly feel like someone could make you angry enough that you would pull out a gun and shoot them… Read more »

joe
Guest
joe

Actually thats why I DON’T own a gun. I have a temper I have done many irrational things when in the process of losing said temper. (my lack of discernible knuckles on both hands is testament to how many times i have blown my top and punched something innanimate)

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

Kudos for knowing yourself that well and recognizing the fact.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Joe, you remind me of one of my nephews. Glad that you know your limits. He is unemployed, 31 years old, still lives with his parents, and has destroyed the interior of their home due to his violent temper. They stopped repairing the damage because it got too expensive. However, he does own a handgun, but would never use it in anger. He’s into martial arts, and doesn’t ever want to hurt anyone, but feels the training helps with his anger management. Unfortunately, he still looses his temper often enough. He probably needs therapy and possibly drugs to help him.… Read more »

Gil
Guest
Gil

So he conveniently trashes the one place where the owners won’t press criminal charges?

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, conveniently? I guess you would prefer that he beats someone or destroys someone else’s property? It’s his home. He doesn’t work, so he doesn’t go anywhere. He lives in a suburb where one needs to have a vehicle to get anywhere. Where else would he be? So, I guess one could call that convenient, since he would have to walk several miles to go somewhere else. He isn’t a criminal. He is a decent person. When he gets angry, he doesn’t attack anyone, he vents his frustration on the walls and doors of his home. Not good, but he… Read more »

Gil
Guest
Gil

Yes I would prefer he did so he would get his comeuppance. The fact he chooses safe targets for his violence proves he doesn’t have a problem at all rather he’s just selfish git.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, comeuppence? You are one sick individual. It’s better that he destroys someone else’s property? What about that property owner that suffers damage to his/her property? You do realize that he would be unable to pay for the damage, and insurance only covers replacement value less a deductible? Then there is the issue that certain items might not be able to be replaced. As far as destroying his parents’ home, they could have him prosecuted, since he is destroying their property. The other issue with that is that the damage is usually minor each time, so the criminal consequences would… Read more »

Gil
Guest
Gil

You said he lives with his parents hence it’s his parents’ house not his. Even paying board to his parents doesn’t give him the right to trash the house. How long would he last if he did that to a rental? Shame on his parents for their soft touch and raising a Special Little Snowflake.

Ricky
Guest
Ricky

Ooh this is such a good one. I was dating a girl for almost 4 years and midway through that I got my first gun (Glock 19). Then I got an AR, then it was a 1911. I eventually got my concealed carry license and started carrying my Glock. She knew I had a CCH but didnt know I carried. I knew she didnt like me carrying a gun but I did anyway for self defense. She really hated guns and wanted to basically disarm me, saying if we ever move in together she wants all the guns locked in… Read more »

Roger V. Tranfaglia
Guest
Roger V. Tranfaglia

Sounds like my sis, a REAL MOONBAT!!!

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@BJI are you trying to sound like “gil”?

BJI
Guest
BJI

Hi ov! You misunderstood my post. I was merely adding to the list of ridiculous comments made by antis.
Personally, I subscribe to the saying: “Kill ’em ALL (those attempting to kill or do great bodily harm to me, my family or other innocents) and let GOD sort ’em out”!!!

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@BJI I stand corrected. We are having heavy weather here tonight. this page just now up dated. I see you posted at 5:26

Pat George
Guest
Pat George

AMEN, Bro!

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@BJI your comment has not come up yet. Who is the attacker attacking? You ? If he kills you do you get your fair trial, what were you being tried for? If someone else are you prepared to let someone else be injured or killed just so the attacker can get a fair trial?

Don Bailey
Guest
Don Bailey

I learned a long time ago, don’t get into a conversation with a liberal professor who asks you, “Why do you need a machine gun that holds a hundred bullets?” The answer was that he didn’t want a logical answer, but he did want to let the world know that every kind of gun was evil.

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

I asked one like that “Why do you need a car that goes 160 mph?”

“That’s completely different!”

“Sure . . . kills far more people every year.”

He didn’t talk to me after that, which was just fine.

Gil
Guest
Gil

Au contraire. In both cases you have that which can extremely rarely be used legally.

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

Wrong. Take it to the range or the race course, respectively.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, that isn’t true. It’s just as legal to use as any other firearm. If one is hunting, there are already prohibitions on types of weapons and ammunition that is allowed to be used. If one is defending one’s life, any firearm is legal. Many ranges allow automatic weapons and rent them. Due to the cost of automatic weapons, since the 1986 ban on the sale of new automatic weapons to the public, and the extensive FBI background check needed, automatic weapons are not readily available, and would generally not be wise to use in self-defense because police typically confiscate… Read more »

Eric_CA
Guest
Eric_CA

Webfoot, excellent rebuttal. I’ll have to remember that one.

BJI
Guest
BJI

How about:
If you kill an attacker you are depriving that person of a fair trial before a jury of their peers!!!

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@BJI, The law of self defense does not require one to consider his attacker’s right to a fair trial. That does not enter into the analysis. Perhaps the attacker should stop and consider his own right to a fair trial.

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@BJI, Oh, that is satire! Silly me.

BJI
Guest
BJI

NOT silly you, Wild Bill!!! I wasn’t PERFECTLY clear. I should have written something like: Add THIS to the list of idiotic antis reasons for not owning a gun. By-the-way, guys, I ALSO am a 78-1/2 year “old vet” altho I really am not NEARLY as much of one as many of you folks. I DID volunteer for the US Army immediately after graduating college just before our heavy involvement in Viet Nam. I DID serve for 2 years, 11 months and 18 days from 1962-1965. As a member of Headquarters company 1st Armored division I was present when the… Read more »

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

Hey Brother BJI, Thank you for your service, and keep the the satire coming.

Gil
Guest
Gil

I think what he meant to say is when a confrontation turns bad make sure the jury only hear one version of the story.

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Gil, The jury only hearing one side will never happen in our legal system. The prosecutor will always tell the state”s side and your attorney will always tell your side. I am sure that you knew that when you made your statement.

Gil
Guest
Gil

Au contraire. There was only one witness to testify in the Trayvon vs Zimmerman case. Could you suppose what would be like if Trayvon lived to tell his side of the story and put on an innocent victim act? Hence in a similar situation you’re better off making sure there’s only account of what happened to the jury.

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

The 911 dispatcher testified too.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, and the decedent’s girl friend testified he was going to attack the person following him.

Gil
Guest
Gil

But there was only one direct witness to actual event in question. As having been on a jury having a one-sided account beats a two-sided account. Hence in some extreme cases there’s no incentive to let the crook survive.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, however, as Zimmerman was getting his head bashed into the found, I am quite sure he was thinking let me make sure the one shot I shoot kills him so there are no witnesses to my getting my head cracked open. Even though the assailant would *not* be a witness to his crime. It’s unlikely Zimmerman beat his head into the ground after shooting his assailant, so as to have justification for shooting his assailant. You are allowed your opinion, but you can’t use your opinion as fact. The facts made it clear that the decedent attacked Zimmerman, and… Read more »

Gil
Guest
Gil

You’d be surprised as the story Martin would have come up to say how he was acting in self-defense against someone trying to murder him. There’d be a pretty good chance it would made the jury uncertain which way to rule.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, again, your opinion is not fact, and that is extremely unlikely as his girlfriend stated he was going to give Zimmerman a beating – that’s not self-defense, and once that is entered as evidence, it precludes any self-defense aspect. That is in addition to the decedent being on top of Zimmerman, bashing his head into the ground, which, again, is not self-defense. The trial is over and Zimmerman was acquitted – that is the fact and the reality.

Gil
Guest
Gil

And as said Zimmerman had it a lot easier in the courts ending Martin’s life than seriously wounding him and letting him live.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, no, Zimmerman was in court being tried for murder *because* Martin died.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Gil, we are not responsible for a criminal’s poor choice of victim. You would be a safe choice for a criminal, except there literally would be no monetary reason to select you as a victim, and criminals can tell that.

Pat George
Guest
Pat George

ANYONE WHO WOULD HARM A WOMAN OR CHILD HAS NO RIGHTS!!!

tom
Guest
tom

I know a man who emphaticly says he would not use deadly force to stop a man from rapeing and killing his wife and children

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Tom, that is *not* the definition of a *man*.

Pat George
Guest
Pat George

Merciful HEAVEN dose that peace of hot air really think that would make them proud of him???! To some people FORCE is the only language they understand. You really need to speak it fluently, all the way from hand to hand stuff (check out Target Focus Training) out to the point where any other tool is appropriate!! I didn’t worry too much about, it until got a bit crippled up. We’ve always rural, so I guess I was naïve, and lucky, but luck isn’t something I like COUNTING on especially with my little ones!

Big Bill
Guest
Big Bill

Todd, not to just be “that guy,” but I have you beat.
When my mother found out I owned a gun, her comment was, “They you’re a murderer.”

Cal-MI
Guest
Cal-MI

Probably more logical to say that if you own an automobile, you are a murderer.

Mike Murray
Guest
Mike Murray

I don’t care who doesn’t like guns, as long as they are willing to LET ME HAVE THEM!
It’s the idea they should tell me how to live based on their likes and dislikes that is the problem.

Tionico
Guest
Tionico

Mike murray, I’ve got a few friends who are vegan or vegetarian… strange, but we have some strong common interests. I DO NOT LIKE tofu, But I have no problem with THEM eating the stuff.. just don’t sneak it into MY supper and tell me its chicken. None of those folk have ever tried to dissuade me from my avid love of meat, any kind fixed any way just about any time. Nor do I argue with them that they likely are not getting enough of ALL the amino acids they need…..

Ricochet007
Guest
Ricochet007

I’m not a vegetarian either, but I do like vegetarian burgers (as opposed to veggie burgers). After all, cows are vegetarians aren’t they?

Crotalus Maxximus
Guest
Crotalus Maxximus

Yep. That old bumper sticker. ” VEGETARIAN, Indian word for Bad Hunter”

Jimbo66
Guest
Jimbo66

I just wanted to say, Great Article. I’ve bitten my tongue to at least 3/4 of those at least once. I used to defend the reasons everyone that can Should own and know how to use guns. All the while never admitting to gun ownership. I’ve found in my 50 something years that sometimes you just can’t fix stupid. I never thought my sister would buy a handgun but she did and now we’re working on teaching her. Good for her. My Daughter has already had to use the gun safety and common sense she was raised with to defend… Read more »

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

I’ve said it before I’ll probably say it again. My kids were taught “Every gun in my house is always loaded, (even if it wasn’t) so you don’t have to check! You don’t get it out to ” play with “. now there has to be a reward just like training an animal. So if you ask we will take them out to shoot together . You don’t tell other kids about what we have, your friends may be trustworthy but all it takes is someone to hear or tell someone about a neat old gun resulting in a burglary… Read more »

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

And about FB just too much personal info on it, just for fun see what kind of info you can compile about a friend. there was a article on the local news that said after 150 likes FB knew as much about you as your parents, and they do collect it !

VT Patriot
Guest
VT Patriot

oldvet, love your comment about ‘reward just like training an animal’. Most everyone I know here in VT are gun owners, hunters, and a shotgun behind every kitchen door. But we have to re fight the battle every year with the snowflakes trying to ‘improve the gun laws’. They have one little problem with that, our state constitution has the 2A as one of articles of our state constitution. They aren’t living in a vacuum, they just have their own agenda.
Thanx, I’ll remember that catchy phrase, I love it.

Ricochet007
Guest
Ricochet007

If you like catchy phrases, here’s one for you: “What’s dumber than bringing a knife to a gun fight? — Bringing a sign* to a gun fight.” (*gun-free zone) or, to an anti-gunner: “Gun controls don’t protect anybody except criminals and tyrants, which one are you for?”

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@VT Patriot be my guest it was not ment to be catchy just statement of fact, just something to enforce that there are correct ways to do things.

Mike Harmon
Guest
Mike Harmon

“You don’t keep them in the HOUSE do you?”

TheSp8
Guest
TheSp8

I have an ultra leftist cousin that claims gun owner status due to having a shotgun in the closet. He frequently spouts the “armed self defense is a fantasy” claim as well as the tired old “common sense, reasonable gun control” crap. He’s also used the “guns are just for killing” and “You’re more likely to be shot with your own gun” line of reasoning. He also thinks you can talk your way out of needing to use a firearm because he talked his way out of a situation once that obviously wasn’t life threatening. For good measure, he’ll throw… Read more »

Ricochet007
Guest
Ricochet007

Probably at least one or two out of nine people you know might have those views, and you just aren’t aware of it. Hopefully the other seven match up like the seven in the given example. After all, how many liberal politicians and media persons are out there? Your ultra leftist cousin sounds as hypocritical as most liberals. So does he expect to meet his own demist from his closet shotgun, or is he going to be “an exception?” Ask him if he’s proposing to disarm cops, since suicide stats show law enforcement as one of the most stressful and… Read more »

gandolf
Guest
gandolf

We live in NJ and are members of an Episcopal Church. The Episcopal Bishop of NJ sent all the Churches his anti gun screed stating every lying antigun factoid from Brady, Bloomberg and other morons. Unfortunately NJ is one of those deep blue antigun States. We can’t carry anything, not a baton, pepper spray, stun gun, taser, slingshot, BB gun or a crossbow. NJ also has two ghetto cities in the FBI top ten gun murder cities. Camden 5th and Newark 6th in a tiny State with 8 million population. Every one of the top ten cities are in deep… Read more »

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@gandolf, Texas is calling.

gandolf
Guest
gandolf

Wild Bill we hear Texas calling. Believe it or not I was born in NJ in 1949 and there is much history, beauty and diverse areas to be found here that has keep my wife and I here. Seashore, forests, mountains and pinelands with bird watching, fishing and hunting abound. As re-enactors we are involved with Rev War and Civil War here. Much of the Rev War battles took place in NJ. We are torn between leaving and staying. A friend of mine was originally from Texas and moved to Pennsylvania many years ago. He finally is returning to Texas… Read more »

Heart of TEXAS
Guest
Heart of TEXAS

On Mother’s Day I sent a text message with photo of the family (wife, daughters, grandkids) to the rest of the family unfortunate enough to not live in Texas. The photo was of all of them lined up shooting .22 rifles.
The “Kalifornia” cousin sent back the comment “Oh, practicing killing people”.
She has since been deleted from the group list. I will send her a card for special occasions with pictures of the range we have built on the ranch and us using it.

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Send her a picture of a bulldozer with the caption “in Texas we know how to bury the bodies where no one will find them!”.

Todd
Guest
Todd

I too have had many friends and relatives say things like why do you need a gun we live in a safe town. A couple of years ago I posted a picture of a new gun that had just been released that I wanted on FB and a family member posted something to the affect of “Why do you want that? All that will do is that you’ll end up in jail or something will happen to your two beautiful daughters with one of those around”. Needless to say I schooled her on why I owned firearms, that I would… Read more »

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Todd, Why do you have anything on FB at all? FB is anti Second Amendment Civil Rights. FB is really poor Opsec. Everything you put on FB can be used against you in court or by a regulatory agency.

Graystone
Guest
Graystone

Wild Bill
Right on re: FB! Too much info, accessable by too many people, usually about too little!
And I might add for people to into themselves or are to insecure.

Jack
Guest
Jack

They really are scary. Fire and metal things fly out of the front of the thingie, then the area is contaminated by unhealthy smoke and the noise–oh the noise–it is terrible and it scares away song birds. Guns are scary things! We have a sign outside our house saying there is a mean lady in here with a broom–so far no one has attacked us. I think every house should have a mean lady and a broom–crime would drop.

Rkn
Guest
Rkn

I’m with you. Guns are scary and they might just go off. Also why does anyone need more than ten rounds? If they would just learn to hit what their shooting at while they are being ambushed by two thugs and they are moving around and zigzag zag going! GEE, when I’m at the range I hit the bullseye everything with just one round on that peace of paper that I know is just hanging there! People who own and carry guns are just wishing for something to happen and most of them are backwoods hillbillies who walk around wearing… Read more »

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

Just a dadgum minute thar pardner, I DO NOT have a hat that says Glock. Might have a shirt or two stashed away though, but that’s a different story.

Cowboy Dan
Guest
Cowboy Dan

I don’t know what happened to my Glock shirts. I used to shoot the Glock meets and got a shirt for my entrance fees each time. I should have three or four somewhere around here.

I was never good enough to win one of the guns, but I came close.

Jim S
Guest
Jim S

Shoot, I have a shirt that says Desert Eagle

Vanns40
Guest
Vanns40

I always thought they preferred the mountains? Hmm, learn something every day!

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Vanns40, apparently not the .50 caliber ones. 🙂

Wild Bill
Guest
Wild Bill

@Rkn, That was funny!

Jimbo66
Guest
Jimbo66

You’ve got that right Wild Bill.

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

@Jack The only shirt I have other than Harley Davidson (what ever town) says “I love my country its the government I can’t trust”. You have any extras you could send me? My hat has N W T F, no that’s National Wild Turkey Foundation. Really officer I didn’t know!

oldvet
Guest
oldvet

Sorry that should have been to Rkn…

Tionico
Guest
Tionico

Hah hah.. when I was a kid the other kids on the block all thought MY mom was the nasty old lady with the broom, which she used for daily tramsportation. making US sweep the floor!!! They did not know my Mom. (she never did like guns, though, fought hard to prevent Dad giving me my first twennyritoofle on my twelfth birthday (he got his first on his sixth….) Four years later I did get it…… my next younger sister inherited Mom’s disgust at guns and their ownership, and HER son is one of the most pro gun guys I… Read more »

Anthony w york Jr.
Guest
Anthony w york Jr.

I suppose I should count myself lucky, that I have not ran into an anti-gun person at all, living in small town central Illinois, (yes, Illinois), the area seems to be very pro-gun.

Mike Harmon
Guest
Mike Harmon

Once you get out of cook and lake counties most of Illinois is quite normal, even at that I had a HUGE customer base from those areas (gunsmith) the real problem lies with the carreer politicians and crooked cops.

Shoeless Joe
Guest
Shoeless Joe

Actually, only one small part of Illinois is Normal, and that’s near Bloomington.

Macofjack
Guest
Macofjack

Stay out of Chicago!

HankB
Guest
HankB

Police are very good at preventing crime by their presence – you’re unlikely to be the victim of a crime if there’s a uniformed cop standing next to you or parked in front of your house. (Unless they’ve been ordered to stand down because of political reasons – which is a whole different discussion.) But by the same token, if a criminal DOES target you, your home, or your business, it means he’s already checked to make sure there are no police nearby. If you’re unarmed . . . THEN what do you do? With today’s violent criminals, meek compliance… Read more »

Crotalus Maxximus
Guest
Crotalus Maxximus

There is a Milwaukee Police station on the far west side of town. The neighborhood has gone down hill to the extent that the apartments right down the block, and in fact right next door are a regular crime scene of robbery murder and drug related assaults.

Pete
Guest
Pete

When I’m on a table at a gun show I tell people “need” is the “N-word.” I’ve also always liked the cartoon of the sign in front of the house that reads to the effect that you’re armed, you next door neighbor doesn’t own a gun, and you promise not to intervene if the burglar/robber goes there instead. As to the police, I’ve always liked the sayong “When seconds count, the police are only minutes away.”

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

I had someone at work brag “I don’t know anyone who owns a gun!”

He was very offended when the four of the eight other people present laughed at him . . . I knew three of them were owners and when I inquired, the fourth was too . . . as was one who didn’t laugh.

Six out of a total of nine . . . that’s a little higher than usual.

Resistance is futile
Guest
Resistance is futile

If there was just one more gun owner, we could have Seven Of Nine, then we could really be safe. 😀

Kenneth Waggoner
Guest
Kenneth Waggoner

You just HAD to do it didn’t you………

Laddyboy
Guest
Laddyboy

“Resistance is futile.”

Joe
Guest
Joe

NICE!!!

Gordon
Guest
Gordon

:D:D:D

jeff snowden
Guest
jeff snowden

number nine, number nine, number nine ….

Bandit
Guest
Bandit

Playing the borg number again.

Heed the Call-up
Guest
Heed the Call-up

Maybe so, but we will never know… *but* what we do know is that with over 80k gun owners in Atlanta recently, there was *no* violent crime.

Macofjack
Guest
Macofjack

Borg on you!

Jim S
Guest
Jim S

Shoot, I have a shirt that says Desert Eagle

Jim S
Guest
Jim S

Ignore my idiocy, hit return too fast

gandolf
Guest
gandolf

And I own a compact 9mm Baby Desert Eagle polymer which was distributed my Magnum Research in the late 90s. It was made by IMI and it is one of my favorite guns. If NJ ever lets us carry it will be on my hip.

Tionico
Guest
Tionico

two thirds… hey, thats enough to pass a bill veto proof in the Senate!!! How bout one says anyone lawfully able to possess a gun can carry it anywhere, any time, any way they choose. Maybe even ammend that Second Article of Ammendment to say something like that, just to clarify the meaning intended by our Framers……

SO.. what was the reaction of this guy who claimed he’d never known a gun owner but learned he’d been working with six of them for a long time and never knew it? Any interest in learning more about them on this guy’s part?

Webfoot Logger
Guest
Webfoot Logger

I do not believe he understood what was funny – I certainly didn’t tell him! (I disliked the pompous donkey.. He got fired after getting caught with his hand in the cookie jar a year or two later.) There have been others who were stunned at that discovery . . . including one who discovered that he was the only person in the room who wasn’t a gun owner. . . I was rather startled that it was THAT lopsided and by some of the people who were owners! And see I wasn’t adding too well up there: it was… Read more »

Gil
Guest
Gil

They should have made him “dance.”

Roger V. Tranfaglia
Guest
Roger V. Tranfaglia

NO…That’s NOT who we ARE!!!!
But to see how HIGH he could JUMP that’s a whole ‘nother ball game!

Lyman Hall
Guest
Lyman Hall

I was at an event at a liberal friend’s house. She was on and on about the open carry in Texas debate. We’re in Colorado. She says “But now you can carry a gun ANYWHERE!” and looks at me. I’m carrying, but she doesn’t know. I look at our other friend, the cop, and raise my eyebrows. He knows I’m carrying (it’s his job to look for black belt clips) and I know he’s carrying. SHE should know he’s carrying, It’s his job… We shrug, tell her “I guess you’re right,: and change the subject. Some people are too clueless… Read more »

Sabel
Guest
Sabel

I guess she doesn’t realize that Colorado has been an “Open Carry” state since 1876, eh? Truely clueless.

Macofjack
Guest
Macofjack

Sabel – You could both be right. Colorado is open carry EXCEPT in Denver and any other location that want’s to ban it! Amazing how liberals can take a law and change the entire outlook of a state!

Ostlander
Guest
Ostlander

Why have liberals for friends? I don’t let them in my home.

Eric_CA
Guest
Eric_CA

Funny!