Weapons of Mass Manipulation

Justin Gaertner is a combat wounded U.S. Marine who continues to serve his country as an ICE computer forensics analyst, helping solve criminal cases & rescue abused children. The tattoo shown here is the symbol for his platoon while he fought in Afghanistan.
Justin Gaertner is a combat wounded U.S. Marine who continues to serve his country as an ICE computer forensics analyst, helping solve criminal cases & rescue abused children. The tattoo shown here is the symbol for his platoon while he fought in Afghanistan.

U.S.A.-(Ammoland.com)- Confirmation bias damages reputations. It ruins credibility. It destroys lives.

When researchers ignore contradictory data that undermines their assumptions, junk science prevails. When police conduct investigations with predetermined outcomes, wrongful convictions abound. And when reporters cherry-pick facts and distort images to serve political agendas, media outlets become dangerous weapons of mass manipulation.

Take Talia Lavin, a young journalist who has enjoyed a meteoric rise. Her pedigree appears impeccable on its face: She graduated with a degree in comparative literature from Harvard University six years ago. After graduation, she won a Fulbright Scholar fellowship to study in Ukraine. She “worked in all realms” of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency news agency and wire service, copy-edited for the feminist Lilith Magazine, and contributed stories and translations for the Huffington Post.

Lavin has held the coveted position of “fact-checker” for the revered New Yorker for the past three years. The publication brags that its “fact-checking department is known for its high standards.” It demands the ability “to quickly analyze a manuscript for factual errors, logical flaws, and significant omissions.” The editorial department requires “a strong understanding of ethical reporting standards and practices” and prefers “proficiency or fluency in a second language.”

Impressively, Lavin speaks four languages (Russian, Hebrew, Ukrainian and English). Her abdication of ethical reporting standards, however, raises fundamental questions not only about her competence but also about her integrity — not to mention the New Yorker’s journalistic judgment.

With a single tweet, the New Yorker’s professional fact-checker smeared Justin Gaertner, a combat-wounded war veteran and computer forensic analyst for the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency.

Lavin, the professional fact-checker, rushed to judgment. She abused her platform. Amid the national media hysteria over President Donald Trump’s border enforcement policies, Lavin derided a photo of Gaertner shared by ICE, which had spotlighted his work rescuing abused children. Scrutinizing his tattoos, she claimed an image on his left elbow was an Iron Cross — a symbol of valor commonly and erroneously linked to Nazis.

The meme spread like social media tuberculosis: Look! The jackboots at ICE who hate children and families employ a real-life white supremacist.

Only it wasn’t an Iron Cross. It was a Maltese Cross, the symbol of double amputee Gaertner’s platoon in Afghanistan, Titan 2. He lost both legs during an IED-clearing mission and earned the Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal with Combat Valor and the Purple Heart before joining ICE to combat online child exploitation.

When actual military veterans, whom Lavin failed to consult before defaming Gaertner so glibly, pointed out that the image looked more like a Maltese Cross, Lavin deleted her original tweet “so as not to spread misinformation.”

Too damned late. The harm to Gaertner’s name and honor is irreparable and cannot be unseen, unread or unpublished.

The New Yorker issued an obligatory apology and acknowledged that “a staff member erroneously made a derogatory assumption about ICE agent Justin Gaertner’s tattoo.” But what consequences will there be for her journalistic malpractice? Who is supervising her work at the famed publication? What other lapses might she be responsible for during her present and past stints as a checker of facts and arbiter of truth?

The magazine editors claim “we in no way share the viewpoint expressed in this tweet,” yet the abject ignorance of, and knee-jerk bigotry against, law enforcement, immigration enforcement and the military underlying Lavin’s slime run rampant in New York media circles. And they all know it.

Lavin has not commented on the matter and instead turned her Twitter account private. But we can infer her attitude about her present troubles from a defiant piece she published just last week in The Forward magazine, where she pens a regular column. Titled “No, We Don’t Have To Be Friends with Trump Supporters,” the piece, laden with Nazi allusions, decries asylum reform, strengthened borders and ICE agents enforcing the law.

Rejecting calls for decency in public debate over these contentious matters, she spat:

“(T)ough nuts, sugar. When they go low, stomp them on the head.”

She further raged:

“It is high time, when you find yourself next at a dinner party with someone who has gone Trump, to smash your glass to shards and leave. It is time to push yourself away from the table. It is time to cease to behave with subservient politesse towards those who embrace barbarity with unfettered glee.”

Better “gone Trump” than gone mad. In her unfettered haste to condemn those with whom she disagrees, the New Yorker’s professional fact-checker failed to check her own toxic biases. Lavin’s act was no innocent gaffe. Like the journalists-turned-propagandists who have falsely spread Obama-era photos of immigrant detention centers to attack the Trump White House, Lavin engaged in mass manipulation under the guise of resistance journalism.

Truth is collateral damage.


About Michelle MalkinMichelle Malkin

Michelle Malkin is host of “Michelle Malkin Investigates” on CRTV.com. As well as the author of “Culture of Corruption: Obama and his Team of Tax Cheats, Crooks and Cronies” & “Unhinged: Exposing Liberals Gone Wild“. Her email address is [email protected]

  • 10 thoughts on “Weapons of Mass Manipulation

    1. @Missouri Born I can think of a series of titles that would fit her but Ammoland might not allow my post.

      Michelle Malkin is always on target and this lizzie could take lessons from her.

    2. This is one Marine combat-wounded double amputee that would have no hesitation in “smashing a glass into shards”, but in this case, over this slimy hypocrite’s arrogant head. With the contents, as well.

      Thank you for bringing this to light, Michelle. Truth Warrior!

    3. Thanx for this article Michelle, It is amazing how many creatures still exist in “the swamp” that most of us have never heard of. I don’t get any of these trash magazines, tho I know they exist. It is evident every day in the ‘trash papers’ that abound in our once great country. If it wasn’t for the trash these fake news outlets thrive on, they wouldn’t have any news at all. I stopped buying them after my bird died. Didn’t need any cage liners after that.

    4. We all have bias, but her’s has crossed into madness. Anger and hate turn to rage, and it warps the body, mind, and spirit. It will turn any of us into a monster. The sad reality is many veterans have crossed the line to serve their nation in the call of duty, and the political left is using half-truths to vilify Trump and his supporters. The POTUS said immigration has been separating children from families since 1997 to protect them from exploitation by adult illegals and he used the term regulations I believe. The media fact-checked it and lied saying it was not law or executive order. Both of which the POTUS never said nor claimed. Now that the POTUS is enforcing the law, this old practice is a fixation of the liberal left in their continued delusional quest to smear President Trump. They are predating on our lack of attention to detail and spitting half-truths: disinformation and propaganda. Sadly this policy change will result in the predation of illegal children and increased hardship. But they don’t really care, all they care about is smearing the POTUS. Because hate and anger is all they have left to offer: their party the DNC has proven to no longer have anything to offer the American people other than lies and deception. Ousting Sanders and planting political agents in the fed via bribery has been their modus operandi for some time.

    5. Michelle, damn good write up and thanks for recognizing, here, and hopefully on Fox and Friend’s, the contunued dispulsion of facts by msm. No matter the media outlet, when liberal minds work together you can bet fact checking is out the window. This makes all the work they have done in the past, no matter hiw well done, BS!

      The left has not only lost all credibility, they have long since become mere agitators and school yard bullies.
      The left makes a mockery of the US and any issues they claim to represent.

    6. Michelle Malkin continues to exemplify true journalism, and is a credit to both herself, her employer, and America. Keep it up.

    7. Talia Lavin is just the kind of person that could help spark a nice armed libtard revolt, and then we could justifiably … kill them. Go Talia!

    8. Thank you Mrs. Malkin for a very good article. It is a shame for these people who FEEL they have the right to TRASH and HUMILIATE hard working Americans who want to live in peace without being TOLD what they can and cannot do.

    9. I would like to know who paid for the buses that hauled the illegal immigrants from South America to our border. And who fed them while traveling. Aren’t those same people responsible the the care of these immigrants now that they are at the border?

    10. As a Harvard graduate it just shows she is another educated idiot who doesn’t check her facts, how ironic since that is her title at the current employer.
      A liberal snowflake would be a better title for her.

    Leave a Comment 10 Comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *