Grand Jury Indictments in Harris County Prosecution of Police in No Knock Raid

U.S.A.-(Ammoland.com)- In the ongoing investigation of the murder of an innocent couple during a Houston no-knock raid, two police officers have been indicted by a Harris County Grand Jury.

On 28 January, 2019, a no-knock raid was executed at 7815 Harding Street, the residence of a longtime married couple of modest means, Dennis Tuttle and his wife of twenty years, Rhogena Nicholas. Neither of the couple had any significant police record.

Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas were the victims.
Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas were the victims.

After the police broke down the door and shot the family dog, Dennis Tuttle fired back in defense. It was claimed he wounded four police officers with a .357 magnum revolver; that claim is uncertain because of how the crime scene evidence was collected.

Many police claims about the raid were disputed early. Investigations by Harris County, the Houston P.D., the FBI and a private forensics firm have been ongoing.

The Harris County District Attorney, Kim Ogg, announced felony charges and arrests of retired officers Gerald Goines and Steven Bryant of the Houston Police Department in August, 2019. The two officers were described as partners. Both retired two months after the Harding Street Raid, while the investigations were ongoing.

The Harris County DA took the unusual step of arresting the accused before a grand jury investigation.

On 15 January, 2020, the Harris County Grand Jury returned indictments for former officers Gerald Goines and Steven Bryant.  Goines for felony murder and tampering with documents, Bryant for tampering with documents.

Former Officer Goines (white shirt) and Bryant (grey shirt)

Former Sgt Goines was wounded in the raid, and could not speak to investigators. He gave written responses in the hospital. From his hospital bed, he claimed, at different times, five different confidential informants (CI) had made the drug buys claimed in the no-knock warrant. All five CI told investigators they had not purchased drugs at the house. Then Sgt Goines said he had purchased the drugs himself.

The case for the warrant and the raid unraveled.

The federal investigation resulted in warrants on federal charges of deprivation of rights under color of law and of obstruction of justice, of Goines, and of Bryan for falsification of records. In addition, a neighbor, Patricia Ann Garcia, was arrested and charged for false 911 calls.

Image from Texas DPS, as displayed by KHOU; cropped, scaled, and text added by Dean Weingarten

KHOU.com reported that Patricia Ann Garcia had a lengthy criminal record of misdemeanors and a felony theft.  From khou.com:

She was also convicted of felony theft in 1995. The rest of her long rap sheet is misdemeanors — five thefts, an assault of a family member in 2013, four driving while license suspended, with the last one in 2016 and one possession of marijuana.

The Harris County DA, Kim Ogg, said this grand jury will be dismissed near the end of the January, 2020. The investigation will continue in two more phases, each with a grand jury empaneled for about three months. The next phase should start early in February.

The second phase will concern itself with a review of additional officers and the potential of additional charges being brought.

The third phase, which should commence about the end of May, will be concerned with the shooting at Harding Street. From the press conference, DA Ogg:

“Phase three will be an investigation into the shooting itself and the other members of the squad who were in “the stack”; when the home was entered, the door was breached, and the family killed.”

The third phase of the investigation may answer questions about who fired what firearms, at what time, and at what targets.

Harris County has nearly two dozen investigators working on the case, nearly full time. Harris County hired ten additional investigators for this purpose.

DA Ogg said her office is working hard to investigate all leads to any corruption that is involved with this case, with narcotics squad 15 and its eleven members, or with any other case which is brought to them involving police corruption.


About Dean Weingarten:Dean Weingarten

Dean Weingarten has been a peace officer, a military officer, was on the University of Wisconsin Pistol Team for four years, and was first certified to teach firearms safety in 1973. He taught the Arizona concealed carry course for fifteen years until the goal of Constitutional Carry was attained. He has degrees in meteorology and mining engineering, and retired from the Department of Defense after a 30 year career in Army Research, Development, Testing, and Evaluation.

23
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
12 Comment threads
11 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
19 Comment authors
PAF145BlueCat49Ej harbetHeed the Call-upRayJN Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
PAF145
Member
PAF145

Very strange -considering how dirty Harris county D.A. is

BlueCat49
Member
BlueCat49

Long gone are the days when we would assume that the police were in the “right”. This is why we need the protections of the “rule of law” and “presumed innocence”. Enough with the “night-time” raids. What about a phone call to tell them to come out with their hands up? Don’t give me any BS about people not complying. Isn’t the “standard” ONE innocent life? Here we lost TWO. Has anyone else noticed that while the annual drug roundups get bigger every year, they do NOT SOLVE the drug problem in a county? It just gets BIGGER every year.… Read more »

Ej harbet
Member
Ej harbet

Good info on what is basically another government sanctioned randy weaver style murder fest.may justice be done against these feinds!

American Patriot
Member
American Patriot

Hmmm….Black officers….White dead people. How would this story be spun if it were the other way around?

freedom isnt cheap
Member
freedom isnt cheap

exactly,,,also why the were targeted …and MURDERED… I am all behind LEO ,but this is murder by lying thugs with badges

Will
Member
Will

@freedom,I’m with LE too. But Goines has not only given HPD a black eye but LE all over the country. That SOB directly led to these people getting killed! They were minding their own business and the police broke into their house and shot them! Goines had been lying on warrant applications for years and that entire process needs to be looked at and fixed. People in prison now due to Goines need to have their cases reviewed and possibly have sentences reduced or be released. Damn this pisses me off!!!

RayJN
Member
RayJN

I support law enforcement, however
From 2011:
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/jose-guerena-arizona-_n_867020
More lying and cover up
Article on No-knock raids:
https://www.vox.com/2014/10/29/7083371/swat-no-knock-raids-police-killed-civilians-dangerous-work-drugs
Makes me wonder how many carry an “insurance baggie” in their pocket.

Firewagon
Member
Firewagon

“No Knock,” “Red Flag,” my joint and there will be ‘knockback!’ I have cameras and alarms that can not be ‘shut down,’ which says ‘I’m waiting for you.’

rotten-ron
Member
rotten-ron

Seems like all those involved with initiating and approving the “red flag” laws and no-knock raids should be held responsible along with the officers!! My home is my castle and it will be defended, I will not take the time to try to authenticate a uniform from a costume in a home invasion!!!

jack mac
Member
jack mac

Ten more enforcers to investigate enforcers, plus the money to support them. The DA has turned this murder into a power increasing money making project. I do not see the public service provided by this public servant. It is the office of the DA that prosecutes cases on false evidence provided by enforcers. The two enforcers here indicted can not be only enforcers providing such evidence. Blame is on the public servants who hire and direct their public enforcers. Citizens ought be concerned more of being evaded by government enforcers than by private criminals. Think of which group with authority… Read more »

Bowserb46
Member
Bowserb46

Folks, this is ANOTHER wake up call. Does anyone not think this is also the ultimate goal of Red Flag laws? Kim Ogg is a bleeding Democrat looking at two murdered white people, a black LEO, and an Hispanic who triggered the illegal raid. Ogg is desperately looking for a way to be a hero to her electorate, who recently re elected a criminal black mayor and an Hispanic woman as County Judge (that’s the county equivalent of a mayor) who had never had a job and whose entire life had been going to school and colleges at taxpayer expense.… Read more »

Heed the Call-up
Member
Heed the Call-up

Stop blaming voters for this by claiming they did not vote. I voted, and many in my county voted. Unfortunately, my county district also included part of the city with many more eligible voters than the county. Even then, the Democrat only won by a few percent – strictly due to the city vote, too many to overcome. It’s not voters not voting, but the lack of education and understanding. People “believe” in “gun control” because it “feels” good and “sounds” reasonable. It is our job to educate those willing to listen. It isn’t an easy task because most people… Read more »

joefoam
Member
joefoam

So the LEOs get carve outs from gun control as they are paragons of virtue? It appears that is not the case. And there are claims that red flag laws can make everyone safer and they won’t be abused. Yeah, and the moon is made of cheese.

Firewagon
Member
Firewagon

Already more than one dead from ‘false’ ‘Red Flag’ nonsense! They can get me, but it aint-a-gunna-be-fun….

Deplorable Bill
Member
Deplorable Bill

Yup, I remember this one. “Cops” broke open the door, murdered the dog. Husband sees someone in his house who is not supposed to be there and see’s his dog shot and murdered. Husband engages the threat and wounds him. Attacker flops onto the couch. Wife tries to remove the threats shotgun and gets murdered by gunfire from OUTSIDE an window.. Other attackers enter and kill the husband. About a half hour later there are two or three shots from inside the house. E M S has not arrived yet when this happened. Husband and wife are murdered along with… Read more »

Vanns40
Member
Vanns40

As a retired LEO I have been and will continue to be an outspoken critic of “no-knock” warrants. They jeopardize the safety of police and citizens. There are better tactics to use.

notademonrat
Member
notademonrat

It’s readily apparent that the government has learned nothing from their no-know raid in Waco. You have to wonder if they don’t care?

Will
Member
Will

Goines criminal actions led to the deaths of two very innocent people. He will escape the death penalty because the of lack of premeditation. But he should get life without in the TDCJ. The relatives of the victims should sue Harris Co.and the State of TEXAS for an absolutely obscene amount of money,…lots and lots of 0’s. They will easily prevail too. I just wonder how many innocent people are in prison right now because of Goines lying on search warrant applications over the years. They all need to be reviewed by the DA’s office for the sake of justice.… Read more »

Knute
Member
Knute

Interesting. Here in Montana the LEOs have children that chase down other teens, murder them, and then get their daddies to pin the blame on Barry Beach. And when found out decades later, and the case gets moved to Lewistown for retrial, the chief crook in charge gets into a bar fight in Lewistown, throws some random stranger out of a plate glass window, and doesn’t even get arrested, let alone made to pay for the window he broke (not to mention the out of stater that he put in the hospital. No harm done, just letting off a little… Read more »

Bowserb46
Member
Bowserb46

Mayor Turner of Houston has a solution. The city no longer provides ammunition for police officers to practice at the range. If they want to practice, they have to buy their own ammo. I guess he figures maybe they’ll miss and save Houston from future lawsuits like what must be coming from this illegal raid. Meanwhile the honest officers pay the price.

RoyD
Member
RoyD

Thank you Will for writing what I wanted to say and doing it so well.

tetejaun
Member
tetejaun

Awww, come on, guys….these cops were showing the FBI and BATF that they could be good anti-Constitutional assassins, too. It was like a job interview. Go read about all the mass murders during all the ‘no-knock’ raids the FBI and BATF did during the rapist Bill Clinton administration. Neal Knox kept everyone informed of their crimes. Their favorite method was a no-knock, then hose down everyone in the home with machine gun bullets. It was NOT carried in the media. If they did not kill the folks indoors, they would arrest them and hog-tie them, men, women & children, and… Read more »

Bowserb46
Member
Bowserb46

Waco Branch Davidians raid was the extreme example of Clinton administration abuse (for which no one, as best I can tell, was prosecuted.) The ATF wanted to question David Koresh, so they raided the compound and started a 51 day siege by the FBI that ended with burning 76 men, women and children to death. However, it was well known that David Koresh went out running every day on a public road, where it would have been easy to pick him up without attacking innocent people. The raid was later reported to be for “suspected weapons violations.” The ultimate precursor… Read more »