Carjackers Stopped by Armed Driver – Armed Citizen Stories

Carjackers Stopped by Armed Driver - Armed Citizen Stories, iStock-595328708
Carjackers Stopped by Armed Driver – Armed Citizen Stories, iStock-595328708

U.S.A.-( We start with this news report from Fox29 news in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

You drive for Lyft. You get a call to a residential area in Philadelphia at 5 on a Sunday morning. When you pull up to the location, two teenagers run up to your car. One of them has a gun. Your attacker orders you to get out of your car and give him the keys.

You are a gun owner. You have your Pennsylvania License to Carry a concealed firearm. You’re armed this morning. You present your firearm and shoot the armed attacker nearest you.

Your attacker drops his gun. The other attacker puts his arms up in the air, so you don’t shoot him. The wounded attacker shouts to someone in a car nearby and that car drives away. You step away from your car, look around, and then call 911.

Police arrest your two attackers. EMS takes your wounded attacker to the hospital for treatment of a non-life threatening injury to his leg. Police also recover your attacker’s gun. It is a BB gun. The attackers who remained at the scene are 14 and 15 years old.

Lyft says you’re not supposed to carry in your car, but an unarmed driver was carjacked in Philadelphia yesterday. You didn’t want that to happen to you.


Our armed defender did a number of things to save his life. Well before this incident, he recognized that driving the public around is a dangerous job. The defender went to the time and trouble of being publicly armed in Philadelphia. He got his permits. Day after day, he dressed around the gun and carried concealed.

On the morning when he was attacked, our defender recognized what appeared to be an immediate, unavoidable, and lethal threat. It sounds like he kept his head and chose his moment to defend himself. When he had an opportunity, the defender shot his immediate attacker until the threat stopped, then the defender stopped shooting. He did not shoot at the second attacker or at the other car because they were not an immediate threat at that time.

After he defended himself, our defender stayed at the scene. He called 911 and made a statement to the police.

Our society changes everyday. Rideshare services now bring hot food to hungry people at all hours. They are also delivering fresh cars to criminals. The carjacker gets to order up the time and location of their robbery. As he places his order, the carjacker can select or reject the make and model of the car.. and the appearance of the driver.

Carjackings are up across the country, but particularly for rideshare drivers.

There are a number of things that were not mentioned in the news report. Let’s look at what we would want to do if we were in a similar situation.

The defender shot his attacker in the leg. Typically that is hard to do from inside the car, so it looks like the defender might have fired as he opened the door and got out of his car. Shooting from inside your car or shooting as you get out of your car are not the presentations we’re taught in our concealed carry class.

If you can, take a class that goes beyond firearms safety and the minimum required for your carry permit. We can learn to shoot from unusual positions. We can also dry practice our shooting from a seated position.

It is harder to find good opportunities to live fire from unusual positions. For example, I could not usually draw and fire from a seated position at my public range, but I could do so during competitions. In that setting you can learn by watching others as well as from your own experience.

We talked about firearms training, but we also have to talk about the judgments involved. Every shot we take will be judged against the legal standards for justified self-defense. Our defender shot when he faced a threat, and he stopped shooting when that threat was sufficiently diminished. The law is not a fool and it recognizes that it takes a moment to realize our situation has changed. We don’t have to be perfect but we want to be responsible with every shot we fire.

There is more we can learn from this news report. These two attackers were not alone. There was at least one additional accomplice in the car that drove away. Multiple attackers are the rule rather than the exception. That is why we want to look around after we’ve addressed the immediate threat.

There is no easy rule to follow when we decide between moving to safety or staying at the scene. There could be greater safety if we flee. We have to weigh that against the possible loss of evidence or witnesses if we run away. In this case, the second attacker might grab the BB gun and disappear. It is unlikely that the wounded attacker would tell the truth about the attack. Criminals usually run and we don’t want to run if we don’t have to. Each of us will have to weigh the pros and cons of that decision in the moment.

Once we’re safe, we want to call 911. Stay on the call and say little. We give our location. Ask for police and medical support. Say that someone is wounded and the scene is secure. Say that there were additional attackers. Give a description of their car and the way they were headed as they left. Tell the dispatcher what you look like including how you’re dressed.

I suggest you stay on the call so you know when the police are about to arrive. Put your gun away, preferably back into your holster. If not, then put your gun back into your car and lock the doors or trunk.

Give a brief statement to the police when they arrive. Tell them the essential facts and then state your willingness to cooperate. We can say something like this.

I was attacked and I called 911. That man pointed a gun at me and I defended myself. That man was also one of the attackers. I called you as soon as I could. Please arrest them. I’ll press charges and testify in court. I’ll cooperate and give a complete statement after I’ve spoken to my attorney.

Of course you want to tell your story, but now is not the time. You may be handcuffed. You may be arrested. You may be taken to jail until you post bail. You are a mess and this is not the time and place to state your legal case.

Have a legal plan and call them. Your lawyer will negotiate you bail. He will ask you to go over what happened several times, preferably at least once after you’ve had a chance to sleep. Let your lawyer take everything you say and put it into a coherent report. Having an experienced self-defense lawyer also makes it harder for a prosecutor to throw unwarranted charges at you. It happens, and you don’t want to face that alone.

We can plan to save lives, both before, during, and after an attack.

Rob Morse highlights the latest self-defense and other shootings of the week. See what went wrong, what went right, and what we can learn from real-life self-defense with a gun. Even the most justified self-defense shooting can go wrong, especially after the shot. Get the education, the training, and the liability coverage you and your family deserve, join USCCA.

Some of the links on this page are affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, Ammoland will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
El Diablo

I’m a veteran USAF SECURITY FORCES and a Pennsylvania retired police officer and I drive for Lyft, I am armed no matter what…!


Well gee lets see. I am a young person, 13 or 15 and if I jack a car I can get a few thousand dollars which should buy me enough drugs to keep me happy for a few weeks or maybe I can start my own business. If I get caught and don’t kill anyone maybe I will spend a year in juvi and have probation or maybe no time in juvi at all if it’s my first offense. If I kill the person and he is not white, I could wind up in juvi until I turn 21. Hum… Read more »


In Georgia there are “Seven Deadly Sins” or crimes where a youth can be charged as an adult. A former student of mine turned 16 in jail and that week was sentenced to 15 years in prison for his part in an armed carjacking.

Pastor Roy

So, it’s the age old story. This man saved his own life (he didn’t know it was a BB gun). And now he will lose his job.

This is wrong. In states where it is legal to carry a firearm, companies must not be allowed to take away an employees 2nd Amendment right to self defense.


From your mouth to Gods Ears….
Let’s hope SCOTUS sees it that way with this New York Case


I drove for Uber/Lyft for 5 years, 5000+ rides, and was armed every day, and was fully aware that both of them would fire me if they found out.

Pastor Roy

Good for you. I have worked in a number of places that do not allow me to carry a firearm. I have always carried anyway and because I did it right, nobody ever knew I was armed.

I knew that if I ever needed to use my weapon, it would mean my job. But my wife & kids need me more than I need that job.


I’m glad the driver was armed. It could very well have been a real gun and he had no way to know. I never, and I mean never leave my home without being armed and that includes to mow the lawn or BBQ. The world is just too uncertain to be complacent.


Unless there’s a sign posted(they have no force and affect here) I always armed!


Great analysis and great reminders of what to do after an incident. In Georgia, a sign at a business has no force of law. If you are asked to leave then you must. So I carry everywhere except the post office and court house.

Pastor Roy

I carry in the Post Office and I carried while working in the courthouse. Guess what? Nobody ever knew.


Here in Minnesota that sign must be a specific size, font, and be placed at every entrance. Funny thing, those who hate guns do not read the laws and think a single sheet of typing paper will suffice. Funnier yet, those who break laws ignore the signs as well…

Pastor Roy

Me, too. Oh, wait … not true! I’m actually armed even if there’s a sign.


Agreed. I regularly ignore “No Guns Allowed” signs. After all, a bad guy is not only not going to obey the sign, he’s going to see it as a free lunch sign where no one will be able to protect themselves from him as a criminal. Gun free zones are pure Liberal stupidity.

Pa John

Capitalism. Always looking for new and innovative ways to meet people’s needs and make a decent profit in the process. Somebody is going to come up with a high gas mileage car design similar to the old typical big city heavy duty taxis, with a cleverly separated driver’s area protected by bullet proof / resistant materials. I.E. – Somebody pulls a handgun? Tell them to go ahead and shoot! All they’ll be able to do is mess up the outer surface of your nice 3 inch thick bullet proof windows or maybe mar the material on the back of your… Read more »