One Year Later, The Parkland Shooting Remains Controversial

Opinion

Students are brought out of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School after a shooting at the school
Students are brought out of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School after a shooting at the school

Fayetteville, AR – -(AmmoLand.com)- One year ago this week, a deranged young man entered the Parkland High School and murdered seventeen students and members of the staff, while injuring seventeen others.

One student who survived, Jaclyn Corin, has written an editorial for The New York Times to express her objections to what she sees as inaction regarding the attack. She argues that there have been no bipartisan investigations or bills, that if an airliner crashed, there would have been an immediate response, and that she and her fellow members of March for Our Lives are determined to do something.

The analogy with air travel betrays a lack of comprehension of the two technologies involved. When a passenger of an airliner dies, this is a failure—of the machinery, of the regulation, or of the operator. TWA’s Flight 800 crashed likely due to a spark in the fuel tank. Poor maintenance is the cause of many fatal accidents, and Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 and Germanwings Flight 9525 appear to be the result of the pilots’ suicidal behavior. But in all of those examples, what happened was contrary to the design and typical usage of the machine.

By contrast, a gun is a weapon/tool. Now it’s true to say that most guns in private hands are not used in fights between human beings, but unlike a vehicle, a firearm is a tool that has fighting in its design. The question then becomes what fights are justified and which ones are an act of illegitimate violence against innocents. The tool in such fights is incidental to the justification or lack thereof.

What Corin and her fellow activists have neglected to address are the fact that the shooter had a lengthy history of acts of violence and threats to commit the same for over a year prior to the attack and the cowardice of law enforcement officers on the scene who were more concerned for their safety than for that of the staff and students.

Corin blames lawmakers for what she claims to be inaction, but she is careful not to make any suggestions as to what legislation could do.

Certainly, this shooting was shocking, though all needless deaths ought to disturb us, and if she only wishes to remind us of the lives lost, I would have no criticism. But the problem here is that her essay has not been sent out into the void with no associations and no implications. The website for her organization is blacked out today, but her fellow member, David Hogg, has expressed support for at least two of the typical demands of gun control advocates, universal background checks and bans on “assault weapons.” However, their approach all too often is to lead with emotionalism and to demand that we sign a blank check.

I do not mean in any way to negate the horror of what she went through. Her experience is one that she did not deserve to suffer. But millions of American gun owners did not commit that atrocity, and lashing out at us will not prevent crimes in the future. Whatever we are asked to feel or to do in an effort to reduce violence in this country must take this into account.


About Greg CampGreg Camp

Greg Camp has taught English composition and literature since 1998 and is the author of six books, including a western, The Willing Spirit, and Each One, Teach One, with Ranjit Singh on gun politics in America. His books can be found on Amazon. He tweets @gregcampnc.

21 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Michael J

A deterent of equal or greater force is required to repel or discourage a would be attack. It seems law enforcement is only there to take a report or identify the accused or victims. Why are court houses, banks and security details armed? Because it is a proven deterent that these morons cannot grasp.
The wolves are attacking at the hen house because they is
know there is no one to protect them.

Deplorable Bill

Local L.E. had been told about that kid and they failed to stop him. The F.B.I. was told about that kid and they failed to stop him. The security guards were told about that kid and they ran and hid as students and teachers were being murdered. The school cadre–same thing. Now here is the uber driver that had a chance to at least call for help and failed to do so. In as much as they were all complicit by actions and inactions, the kid is the murderer. That being said, the fore mentioned are guilty of negligent homicide,… Read more »

KuhnKat

“TWA’s Flight 800 crashed likely due to a spark in the fuel tank.”

Jet fuel is hard to ignite even when vaporized. Virtually impossible for the power available, allegedly frayed wires to a fuel pump, to cause a spark that could have ignited a fuel tank explosion. In actual testing it took the equivalent of an oxy/acetylene torch to ignite the vapor.

Jack Mac

Dog, I think that all jurisdictions have authority to arrest for terroristic threats. local LEOs to the FBI were aware of the threat and did not properly act. Once the Uber driver let the kid with the rifle case into the car he should have driven him to police station instead to school. Can not you even visualize the possible effects of ERPOs on everybody. Execution of the order does not require evidence. Any one can initiated execution anytime on anybody, meaning you, me, and them. This is a dangerous theat to our civil rights and a deadly threat to… Read more »

Wild Bill

The picture reveals a lot, too. See how the LEOs treat the non suspects? It is easier to bully the community, than go inside the school where the shooting was. The message is clear, the public better obey and demonstrate that they are not armed … for the rest of their lives.

joefoam

Yeah, and they promote ‘see something, say something’ to curb these kinds of attacks. The BCSO saw plenty, the high school admin saw plenty, the viewers of facebook saw plenty, security saw plenty. Nothing was done so the attack went on unabated. The only reason the shooting is controversial is that the authorities failed the citizens completely and they are busy trying to deflect the blame to the weapon used, or the NRA. You would think it was scripted.