An 89-year-old Florida grandfather appears to have been attacked and killed by a black bear during the early morning hours of May 5th, near Jerome, Florida. Jerome is a rural area on the opposite side of the state from Miami, between the Big Cypress Wildlife Management Area and the Fakahatchee Strand Preserve State Park, part of the Everglades.
The relative of 89-year-old Robert Markel called 911 to report that a bear had killed Markel’s dog as the relative had watched, and that the elderly relative was missing. The call was made about 7 a.m. From fox4news.com:
“No, he’s gone completely. His whole camper was destroyed,” the 911 caller said. “He’s not in there. He’s 89-years-old…he can’t run. He literally can’t even walk without falling over,” he added.
The granddaughter told deputies on scene the last time she saw her grandfather was 7:30 p.m. Sunday.
When deputies arrived, the report says the trailer was in disarray, the mattress was off the bed and items were scattered throughout the trailer.
One relative said (video) the dog was tied to a fence outside the camper when the bear attacked Markel and dragged him from the camper. It is not clear if the dog was tied up when it was killed by a bear hours later.
Investigators from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission suspect Robert Markel was killed hours before the 911 call. The call was made at about 7 a.m. If correct, Markel was attacked before daylight in the early morning hours. Sunrise, on May 5th in South Florida, was scheduled for 0641, in Eastern Daylight Time.
Video of the scene showing a woodline indicates the area is heavily forested.
Markel’s pants and bloody t-shirt were found about 20 yards from the camper. His body was found about 100 yards away, in the woods, covered in leaves and dirt. It is common for bears to cover large prey with dirt and forest debris.
So far, three bears have been killed by FWC agents. They are testing the bears for DNA to make sure they remove the offending bear or bears.
A fatality was nearly inevitable with a rapidly expanding black bear population in Florida and increasing bear-human conflicts.
Less than a year ago, Florida Governor DeSantis signed a bill that restored some of the rights of people to defend themselves against bears that threatened themselves, their homes, and their pets. It appears black bears are very common in the area where the fatal attack occurred. If the victim had been able to access nearly any type of firearm, it is likely he would not have been killed. Black bears usually stop attacking if they are hurt or wounded.
The last time an official estimate of the black bear population was in 2014-15. The estimate, at that time, was that there were more than 4,350 bears. Black bear populations, with abundant food and habitat, can easily increase by 15% a year, after subtracting cannibalism by adult male bears and the approximate 300 black bears killed in vehicle accidents in Florida each year.
A new estimate of the Florida black bear population is due shortly. This correspondent has been unable to find any official estimate of the black bear population in Florida since the study conducted in 2014-15.
About Dean Weingarten:
Dean Weingarten has been a peace officer, a military officer, was on the University of Wisconsin Pistol Team for four years, and was first certified to teach firearms safety in 1973. He taught the Arizona concealed carry course for fifteen years until the goal of Constitutional Carry was attained. He has degrees in meteorology and mining engineering, and retired from the Department of Defense after a 30 year career in Army Research, Development, Testing, and Evaluation.
I live in prime black bear country.
Being armed is a everyday occurrence
Another good reason to be armed all the time. Getting eaten alive by a bear is not my first choice is ways to meet the LORD. Looks like the dog had about as much chance as the disabled man did. Sorry way to die.
Arm up and carry on
I can see it now– animal rights groups will lament the fact that bears were killed while ignoring the victim of the attack. To them, animals are more important than people. Hunting of bears should be allowed to control the population, and to condition bears to fear humans.
There is a reason that people hunted large predators to extinction wherever they could in earlier days. Predators that aren’t hunted by humans assume humans are prey. For many years, I loved to walk my dog at night on property I own in north central Florida. Not any more. I’ve seen panther tracks, and with bear populations expanding, I’m unwilling to risk it. All so people can feel good that there are bears and panthers in the woods they never enter.
if you cant run have a big gun
Florida Black Bears can be found all over Florida. While their preferred habitat is forested land, the forests are shrinking in area which is putting increasing pressure on the bears to move around in and through other habitats. Coupled with bear population replacement rates the chances are increasing that anyone can run into one or more. These bears also don’t “hibernate” or enter torpor for as long a period as bears to the north of Florida, so yet again…one is increasingly likely to run into one or more of them at any given time, AND compared to other bears they… Read more »
Really seems off that it killed both owner and dog then drug the man 100yds away to later eat him I’m guessing. Folks are saying it went into the home to kill him. Doesn’t sound like a typical black bear attack. Heck of a deal.
black bears are almost as common as wild hogs
99% of the time when a person is attacked by a black bear there is a dog involved. for at least 1000 years bears were hunted and treed by dogs then shot. it seems like it is in the bear DNA to connect dogs with being hunted so they start with the dog then go to the master of the dog
This is a sad situation, but something like this is to be expected when bear populations are allowed unlimited increase. At least here in Western North Carolina we are allowed to shoot menacing bears. As mentioned in another post, it’s a good reason to stay armed (and aware).