Is That Pro-Gun Quote Too Good to be True?

Opinion

Sarah Brady
Sarah Brady, she never said that.

United States – -(AmmoLand.com)- When we discussed how our support for the Second Amendment comes across, one of the items mentioned was the importance of maintaining your credibility. There are far too many in the media who seek to help in the cause of those who would take our freedoms away that would eagerly leap to paint us as liars or worse, thus depriving us of a key advantage, we have over the likes of Schumer, Feinstein, Bloomberg, and their ilk. It also hurts efforts to win over local media.

Think it won’t matter? In 1996, Al Salvi was running against Richard Durbin, an avowed opponent of our right to keep and bear arms, for a United States Senate seat. He falsely claimed that former White House Press Secretary James Brady had a Class III FFL. Salvi quickly apologized, but the damage was done, and Durbin is now Chuck Schumer’s sidekick in the Senate.

I wish I could say that’s the only time… but there are others, and many were prevalent in the 1990s, and they stick around today and can be found on many a web site. It is a classic booby trap… just waiting for some poor, unsuspecting Second Amendment supporter to do irreparable damage to their credibility by using them.

One such quote is attributed to Sarah Brady (deceased), and a variation of it is even the top quote on her page at azquotes.com: “Our task of creating a socialist America can only succeed when those who would resist us have been totally disarmed.”

It’s a damning quote – one to explain why the push for semi-auto bans or other laws that are completely ineffective at keeping guns away from bad guys. It explains the motive, nice and neat in a tidy package. There is just one problem:

She never said it!

Sarah Brady, for all her opposition to our right to keep and bear arms, was nowhere near socialism on the political spectrum. Granted she ultimately endorsed Democrats, but she was a lifelong Republican. There are, however, legitimate quotes that she did utter, including one that called for a “needs-based licensing” scheme for firearms.

In a similar vein, in efforts to oppose gun registration, some pull out a quote purportedly from Adolf Hitler: “This year will go down in history! For the first time, a civilized nation has full gun registration! Our streets will be safer, our police more efficient, and the world will follow our lead into the future!”

It’s another damning quote – one that ties the anti-Second Amendment agenda to one of history’s most iconic representations of evil. What could be better to show our moral superiority over the likes of Schumer, Bloomberg, and Feinstein? Again, there’s a problem:

He never said it!

There is no dispute that the Nazis used gun control to disarm their intended victims, including Jews. But we don’t need to resort to a phony quote. We have the history of places like Australia and the United Kingdom. In both countries, law-abiding gun owners who had registered their guns were then told to turn them in when politicians chose to wrongfully punish them for the acts of madmen who carried out mass shootings.

The worst of the phony quotes, though, are the ones allegedly uttered by the Founding Fathers. The most notable of these is the “liberty teeth” speech by George Washington. Guncite.com has outlined how that quote is not confirmed, as well as one by Thomas Jefferson that Gun Owners of America uses on its website. There are a number of real quotes from the Founding Fathers that support our right to keep and bear arms.

Thomas Jefferson said, “No free man shall be debarred the use of arms.”

Patrick Henry said, “The great object is, that every man be armed.”

Richard Henry Lee wrote that, “to preserve liberty it is essential that the whole body of people always possess arms.”

Thomas Paine noted, “[A]rms . . . discourage and keep the invader and the plunderer in awe, and preserve order in the world as well as property.”

Samuel Adams warned that: “The said Constitution be never construed to authorize Congress to infringe the just liberty of the press, or the rights of conscience; or to prevent the people of the United States, who are peaceable citizens, from keeping their own arms.”

If you ever have a doubt about the authenticity of a quote – you can look to some of the links in this article. Guncite.com listed a few phony quotes, as well as the phony ones from the Founding Fathers. If it isn’t listed there, contact the NRA’s Institute for Legislative Action. I can personally attest that they will be able to confirm if a quote is real or if its authenticity is doubtful.

Folks, our credibility is one of the most crucial assets we have in the fight to defend our freedoms. It is always better to tell someone, “I don’t know, but let me find out,” than to make an ass out of yourself and make it easier for the media to paint Second Amendment supporters as liars.

If a quote sounds too good to be true, it’s best to double-check it before you use it.


Harold Hu, chison
Harold Hutchison

About Harold Hutchison

Writer Harold Hutchison has more than a dozen years of experience covering military affairs, international events, U.S. politics, and Second Amendment issues. Harold was consulting senior editor at Soldier of Fortune magazine and is the author of the novel Strike Group Reagan. He has also written for the Daily Caller, National Review, Patriot Post, Strategypage.com, and other national websites.

  • 37
    Leave a Reply

    Please Login to comment
    22 Comment threads
    15 Thread replies
    0 Followers
     
    Most reacted comment
    Hottest comment thread
    30 Comment authors
    ProctorlarcaPeter AnthonyLord-Pi-314freewill Recent comment authors
      Subscribe  
    Notify of
    Proctor
    Guest
    Proctor

    We must be more virtuous than the enemies of freedom and good.

    Peter Anthony
    Guest
    Peter Anthony

    here is one meaningful uh quote from our Founding Fathers

    “the people are the Master
    the government is the Servant
    the people must always be well armed
    les the Master becomes the Servant” [SLAVE]

    & it really doesn’t matter if some Nazi Obama worshipping
    Fake Political Prostitute in the bogus anti-America media
    “re-defines” that such lacks authenticity or not
    what matters is TRUTH of substance
    & thee could NOT be a truer quote or statement of fact ever uttered
    than the above cess pool which the usual evil power abusing\hungry
    Soros Sucking Socialist Democrats have been so obcessed with shoving
    down our throats…

    freewill
    Guest
    freewill

    Since its the bill of rights and the word (people) is in the 1st, 2nd, 4th and 10th amendment..I have to believe our founders meant regulate as..To adjust to a particular standard, rate, amount, degree etc.

    larca
    Guest
    larca

    Back in the late 1700s, “well-regulated” did not imply “controlled” or “ruled”. It meant “in good working order” or “well-practiced” … as in “trained” and/or “skilled”. It referred to those with firearms gathering together periodically in groups of neighbors (local militia groups) and practicing to develop and retain skill with their firearms. You are correct about use of the word People. Expanding on that a bit — in the Constitution, the word People refers to all individual citizens, *not* to the collective citizenry (which is the State). Another related point is that *everywhere* in the Constitution that the word “Right”… Read more »

    Jack
    Guest
    Jack

    This list of firearm quotes is pretty solid:

    http://www.famous-quote.net/quotes-on-firearms.html

    larca
    Guest
    larca

    Thanks for posting that link, Jack! Now bookmarked :-).

    David E. Young
    Guest
    David E. Young

    Quotes can be accurate and yet still far removed from the context in which they originally appeared. Entire documents and full selections from documents that are relevant to a discussion are much to be preferred. There is a complete document collection regarding the Founding Era development of the Second Amendment as part of the U.S. Bill of Rights. The title is The Origin of the Second Amendment. The subtitle: A Documentary History of the Bill of Rights in Commentaries on Liberty, Free Government, and an Armed Populace, 1787-1792. This massive collection of Bill of Rights proposals, related discussions in state… Read more »

    Lord-Pi-314
    Guest
    Lord-Pi-314

    @David…Thank you, thank you, thank you…for imparting your extensive knowledge on the subject. This should all be included in a mandatory class every American student has to take, beginning in kindergarten. It could supplant the “reading with transvestites” brainwashing, or the “sodomy is a healthy lifestyle” horse manure they are now being fed.

    Crazy 1
    Guest
    Crazy 1

    Is there anyone else in this country that can see what I am seeing. This is not the country that I was born into in 1952. I do not have a retarded son that I took to a shooting range to spend quality time with. I took my son to hunt when he was 12 years old and I purchased his first hunting rifle when he was 13. I taught him to respect a gun. Everyone needs to take a serious look at what we have elected as our government in the last 10 years/ Wake up and look at… Read more »

    StLPro2A
    Guest
    StLPro2A

    It makes no difference how stupid or whatever term you might use to describe the Democrat, Anti-American politicians. What matters are the stupid people that will vote for them and their claimed free shit!!!! That has been the Dept. of Education…..er, Indoctrination…..role. Lenin said “Give me the children, and I will change the country.” (paraphrased) The US kids have had revisionist history lies crammed down their throats and have been taught that America is bad. Our country is lost. We older farts will soon die off. The children have been transformed into anti-American traditional principle haters and major pussies and… Read more »

    Nomen Ignotus
    Guest
    Nomen Ignotus

    …not a “quote ” however Article IX of the Bill of Rights : “The enumeration in the Constitution of certain rights shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the People .” I know Justice Scalia was not a fan of this one …but …if you look into it …it is clearly designed to acknowledge that the “Rights ” spoken of are inherent in the citizens and do not come from the bureaucracy ( i.e. ruling class or now “Elites ” ) and that even if not set out in the Bill of Rights there are other… Read more »

    keith
    Guest
    keith

    OK, A bit of a reality check.
    Adolf Hitler did make that quote and it was repeated by John Howard the then prime minister of Australia when they took our semi autos off us in the wake of the port Arthur mass shooting in 1996.
    I have seen both of these comments.

    MikeVinas
    Guest
    MikeVinas

    No, that’s a well know bogus quote. It’s been around for a long time though and is repeated often. Germany already had tough gun control, including registration, imposed by the Weimar Republic. There were no new laws until 1938, when the Nazis relaxed gun laws for ‘good Germans.’

    Art Nickel
    Guest
    Art Nickel

    Today the biggest problem is figuring out the difference between History and REVISIONIST HISTORY…
    One of the biggest problems is that things people have said and the proof of those things are more often than not disappearing from the world, like the picture of Bill Clinton in Moscow in the 1960s.

    Dave C
    Guest
    Dave C

    We wouldn’t need to rely on quotes, if more of the populace had been gifted with common sense. (You can quote me)

    Wild Bill
    Guest
    Wild Bill

    @Harold Hutchinson, how do you know for a fact that they never said it? Can you prove that then never said it? Maybe they never said in in a speech or documented writing, but said it to no one in particular while walking from their chauffeured limousine to lunch. Maybe “what they said” was on the first draft of a speech, thrown away, and read by a zealous janitor. You don’t know. You just say you know. When something unpalatable is attributed to a Second Amendment patriot, any Second Amendment patriot, that patriot is force to prove that he did… Read more »

    Rokflyer
    Guest
    Rokflyer

    Great commentary and I couldn’t agree any more. I hear well meaning but badly informed helpers to the cause of the 2cd continually, get in deep water over something “they have heard”, it is cause for concern. I personally have learned to abstain from quoting,if incorrect the repercussions are painful.

    Robert Pollard
    Guest
    Robert Pollard

    Unfortunately, I see no end to the “validation” process since non of the people in the NRA-ILA or guncite.com were actually there. There is an inherent danger in using only a couple of sources that say they have the fact checking all worked out. And don’t depend on any other source.
    Can they be absolutely sure that someone was at a small town gathering and didn’t say something? I don’t think so. Nor can they be sure that they did.
    But, the general idea of what he is saying is good but no one can be 100%.

    Robert Pollard
    Guest
    Robert Pollard

    Also, to his point about her not being a socialist, if she is or supports a Democrat, she IS supporting socialism/communism.
    If you don’t know that socialism is communism, do some research.
    Also, if you don’t know the Democratic Party has its roots in Marxism, continue researching. It’s a real eye opener.
    One more thing, take a look at how many Dems have associations with Communism.

    larca
    Guest
    larca

    As much as I would *like* to agree with you, Robert, keep in mind that back in the last century when Sarah Brady was actively involved, the Democratic Party was not associated with Socialism. Heaven knows that they are inextricably linked *today*, but not back then. Sarah Brady was a lifetime Republican, who supported Democrats toward the end probably because only they were supporting gun-control measures (even though all of the measures were ineffective). So it’s unlikely that she supported Socialism in any form (although you might possibly imply that she supported a from of fascism, if she supported disarmament… Read more »

    Roy D.
    Guest
    Roy D.

    Upon seeing that picture did anyone else immediately think, “ET phone home.”

    BillyM
    Guest
    BillyM

    Great article from Harold Hutchison and very relevant to our struggle to maintain our constitutional rights. In our “meme” motivated society it is so easy to advocate for a lie. Sad. Like Hutchison said, the truth can be found as well it should. There is only one truth and there are many lies. Movements, crusades, marches, wars and even laws based on lies and deception will all eventually crumble. It is unfortunate now that truth is relative to whatever; whatever is true for me is truth. That in itself would not be such a terrible thing except that many in… Read more »

    Core
    Guest
    Core

    There are endless quotes to support and armed populace. I believe quotes have become a popular pastime in the US and I honestly have never heard anyone use any of the above quotes. Here’s something to add to the list of legit quotes: Article VI, Supreme Law of the Land! It’s found within the US Constitution and it literally means anyone who is not in good standing with the US Constitution, is to be Defunded, Disbarred, and Discharged from Office, and that all unconstitutional laws and regulations are moot. Quite a quote.. #2A #1A #ArticleVI

    Robert Pollard
    Guest
    Robert Pollard

    That’s the best one of them all. Would solve a lot of our pesky communist problems. The big question is, why aren’t the politicians hearing bars shut behind them for this treachery???

    Lord-Pi-314
    Guest
    Lord-Pi-314

    @Robert Pollard….The day may be coming soon. Rumors are that the purge has begun and Military Tribunals have commenced as of Jan. 2 of this year. The MSM has refused to report on this, maybe because they fear that they will eventually be targets also. By law, military tribunals are secret, but some info is allowed to be leaked to special sources. There is info on the net now. Like I say, I am treating this as unconfirmed rumors for the time being, but what has been posted so far is very, very interesting.

    BMcGill
    Guest
    BMcGill

    Great article from Harold Hutchison and very relevant to our struggle to maintain our constitutional rights. In our “meme” motivated society it is so easy to advocate for a lie. Sad. Like Hutchison said, the truth can be found as well it should. There is only one truth and there are many lies. Movements, crusades, marches, wars and even laws based on lies and deception will all eventually crumble. It is unfortunate now that truth is relative to whatever; whatever is true for me is truth. That in itself would not be such a terrible thing except that many in… Read more »

    Jacob
    Guest
    Jacob

    There are enough powerful REAL quotes that we shouldn’t be said when a great quote turns out to be fake. “Among the natural rights of the colonists are these: First a right to life, secondly to liberty, and thirdly to property; together with the right to defend them in the best manner they can.” – Samuel Adams “They currently have guns, and therefore we are for ‘peace’ and ‘reformation through the ballot.’ When we have all the guns, then it will be through the bullet.”’ ~ Saul Alinsky “The people in the various provinces are strictly forbidden to have in… Read more »

    Michael
    Guest
    Michael

    It’s like that movie from 1856 where Lincoln and Davis are seen discussing how to disarm the south after the war. A buddy of mine told me about it.

    JoeUSooner
    Guest
    JoeUSooner

    LOL !!

    Paul Cavallaro
    Guest
    Paul Cavallaro

    I find that the lies about guns and their owners are encouraged by the left and their lap dog media with NO repercussions, but hell breaks loose when a 2nd amendment supporter makes a “disingenuous” comment. The word lie in progressive lexicon does not exist. Saul Alinsky is smiling up from hell!

    Ton E
    Guest
    Ton E

    I say this all the time when someone uses a fake founders quote. I’m guilty of doing that in the past some people won’t admit they’re wrong and adjust themselves accordingly.

    phil morris
    Guest
    phil morris

    i am in awe of the fact that the left is using the 1st amendment to quash the second amendment , I propose that we ban stupidity/ignorance e.g. you should not be allowed to speak/write about anything you do not obviously/fully understand , and if you do , you should be tied to a post in a public square and beaten brutally about the head and shoulders with a knotted plow line 😉

    MB
    Guest
    MB

    The 2nd amendment protects the rest, lose the 2nd, then the 1st, 4th, 5th and all the others will be meaningless. That’s their goal. There’s a revolution coming, it’s going to make the Bolshevik revolution look like a picnic in the park, but this time the socialists will lose. Keep your powder dry.

    JoeUSooner
    Guest
    JoeUSooner

    Homeland Security agrees with your assessment. It told Congress, in a 2015 “white paper” that a revolution is coming. So, yes indeed… keep your powder dry.

    HankB
    Guest
    HankB

    Some leftists and Democrats (is THAT a modern redundancy, or what!?) have recently been heard suggesting outright repeal of the 2nd Amendment. THAT ought to be a warning for EVERYONE, since if the 2nd were to be repealed, it would establish a precedent to repeal ALL of the Bill of Rights.

    Tionico
    Guest
    Tionico

    Because our liberty teeth have grown dull from lack of use.

    It seems that LIberty Tree is growing thirsty…… will its thirst have to be slaked, or will right and justice preveil without resorting to that?

    n.r.ringlee
    Guest
    n.r.ringlee

    Agreed. But I can tell you from first hand experience that the Progressive New Left has no such compunction about using false information. While an undergrad at a very left wing, probably the most left wing public university in the 1970’s I was introduced to the concept of Noble Fiction in a classical political theory seminar. The prof first referenced it in our Platonic readings and then went on to give examples of noble fictions used by the anti-war movement. There was no such concern among faculty or students at the time and that ethical blind spot seems to have… Read more »