On September 9, 2024, the murder trial of Gerald Goines started in Houston, Texas, more than five years after the killings. The former Houston Police officer, undercover officer, and narcotics squad leader, was charged with the murders of Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nickolas.
On January 28, 2019, undercover Houston drug police raided the residence of Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas, both 58 years old. Both of them and their dog were killed. The raid was caused by a neighbor who lied about the Tuttles, and Officer Gerald Goines lied on an affidavit to obtain a no-knock warrant. From Houstonpublicmedia.org:
During the hearing on Monday, Goines’ defense team acknowledged that the former officer had fabricated a story about a confidential informant purchasing heroin from the couple’s home, but claimed that the murder charges were excessive — “a case of overcharging,” according to attorney Nicole Deborde Hochglaube, who’s representing Goines.
After opening statements, prosecutors questioned Sarah Sanchez, who had lived on Harding Street during the incident and was close with both Tuttle and Nicholas.
Prosecutors questioned Sanchez about Patricia Garcia, a neighbor who made three 911 phone calls on the evening of Jan. 8, 2019, in which she told police that her daughter was doing heroin inside the couple’s home and that the couple were drug dealers and had guns inside their home.
Investigators eventually found that Garcia had no daughter and that her other claims were also false. She was the first person to be sentenced in connection with the deadly raid in June 2021.
“She was always fighting with Rhogena, always jealous of Rhogena,” Sanchez said during Monday’s hearing. “She was very hateful.”
One of the reasons the cover-up of the lies that led up to the raid fell apart might be because Officer Goines was wounded in the neck and could not talk in the hospital. Members of the narcotics squad, which Goines led, were forbidden from communicating with each other while the raid was being investigated. Some of the members of the squad had been in the narcotics division for 20 years or more.
The murder charges against Goines are based on Texas statute Sec. 19.02. (b) (3):
(3) commits or attempts to commit a felony, other than manslaughter, and in the course of and in furtherance of the commission or attempt, or in immediate flight from the commission or attempt, the person commits or attempts to commit an act clearly dangerous to human life that causes the death of an individual;
The prosecution theory is: lying to procure a no-knock warrant, then participating in the no-knock raid is sufficient to meet the standards of the statute.
According to the defense, as recounted in a Reason.com article, Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas were responsible for their own deaths by resisting the no-knock raid after their door was broken down and their dog was shot and killed.
The raid and investigation were covered extensively on AmmoLand. Video coverage from a body camera, a neighbor’s surveillance camera, and cell phone video were important in the investigation.
In addition to the Texas state charges, Goines faces federal charges. Civil lawsuits are ongoing.
The digital age is making it much harder to cover up corruption, at least for individual officers and small units.
About Dean Weingarten:
Dean Weingarten has been a peace officer, a military officer, was on the University of Wisconsin Pistol Team for four years, and was first certified to teach firearms safety in 1973. He taught the Arizona concealed carry course for fifteen years until the goal of Constitutional Carry was attained. He has degrees in meteorology and mining engineering, and retired from the Department of Defense after a 30 year career in Army Research, Development, Testing, and Evaluation.
” Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas were responsible for their own deaths by resisting the no-knock raid after their door was broken down and their dog was shot and killed.” I don’t like no-knocks from an arm chair point of view. There are plenty of opportunities to take someone in custody after an investigation to determine actual facts. It seems like ego’s and the rambo mentality drive these sorts of raids. It militarizes the police against its citizens by whittling away your 4th Amendment rights thru these sorts of power imbalances. If you kicked down my door without knocking, damn right… Read more »
one more bad cop caught but way to many do not get charged
The lie was so unnecessary. Fortunately, nationwide departments are reexamining the value of no-knock warrants, and most have opted to at least require command-level approval to ask for one, while many just flat out ban them. The theory was that evidence could be destroyed if cops have to announce themselves first, but in my experience we always got the evidence we needed. Knocking doesn’t mean you have to wait a long time. We knocked and demanded entry, and counted to 10. If we got no reply, we knocked again and counted to 10. Then, unless someone was responding, we kicked… Read more »
G. Goines is a prime candidate for ole sparky, a big needle or a one way visit from his prison buddies. Goines lied to get a search warrant and he ordered a raid based on that warrant then he actively took part in the murder of two innocent people and their dog. An absolutely innocent man, woman and dog lost their lives due to police and neighbor lies. These people were murdered by the police, who’s job it is, “to protect and defend”. They were also murdered by their evil neighbor from hell. Every cop involved along with the neighbor… Read more »
I did not really know that asshole, but I met him a couple of times. He used to give a couple of hour block of lecture from time to time during our dyate mandated in-service training; recounting his experiences in several questionable shootings that nobody at the time was questioning. I think it also reflects the declining expertise of HPD’s Homicide Division in the 21st Century, which speaks to why our IAD did not climb up his ass a long time ago, which they are famous for.
Against “gun-nuts” false police reporting is quite popular in African-America. And even in real African-Africa!
Politicians’n’lawyers are the David Copperfields of freedom. They distract with one hand, while accomplishing their pick-yo’-pocket sorcery with the unwatched hand. Patriots are jubilant, yeah ecstatic, I tell ya,’ being distracted by hypothetical, unrealized, paper “2A wins/gains,” while the other hand seals their future doom. Until all 23,000+ anti-2A laws are gone, politicians feel the personal risk, we’re not even back to zero on the Freedom Scale. Time is the Great Illusionist. Anti-2A forces play the long game, aka the attrition game. Tempus fugit as America struggles with 50/50 split between the forces of evil for 2024 Presidential election. The… Read more »
It is long past time to abolish the no-knock raid. All too often they are used on innocent people and they have done absolutely nothing to prevent crime or keep us safe. They have led to an ever increasingly militarized police force where swat teams are used on an ever increasing basis in order to justify their bloated budgets and keep funding and military equipment rolling in. They’re used to terrorize communities, violate rights, and steal from us via unconstitutional asset forfeiture laws. These teams should only be used on very rare occasions such as hostage situations or mass shootings.… Read more »
As I recall Goines was injured and unable to complete his planned misdeeds. Believe they found drugs (heroin?) in his vehicle and determined that he intended to plant it in the house so they could “find” it and “win” convictions. Again – as I recall – department decided they need to re-evaluate all cases for all previously arrested by the Goines’ gang. They had had complaints that these cops were planting evidence but choose to believe normal people are no-where near as trustworthy as their own cop-buddies. Admit guilt – you are obviously guilty and probably under-charged, deny guilt and… Read more »
Mortem ad Magistratum. If you’re a cop in a no-knock, I’ve no sympathy for you. You chose to take part in an illegal activity, reap it.