Remembering The Air Force General Who Helped Usher In The M16 Rifle

By Jason J. Brown, former U.S. Air Force staff sergeant
Note: This article was originally posted on NRA Blog

Airman First Class Ray Wilkerson, a crew chief from the 113th Maintenance unit tests sight alignment adjustments during a M16-A2 qualifications course July 16, 2011, at the combat arms training and maintenance center Joint Base Andrews, Md. Airman from the 113th practice and qualify with the M16-A2 July 16, 2011. (U.S. Air Force photos/Tech Sgt. Gareth Buckland/Released)
Airman First Class Ray Wilkerson, a crew chief from the 113th Maintenance unit tests sight alignment adjustments during a M16-A2 qualifications course July 16, 2011, at the combat arms training and maintenance center Joint Base Andrews, Md. Airman from the 113th practice and qualify with the M16-A2 July 16, 2011. (U.S. Air Force photos/Tech Sgt. Gareth Buckland/Released)

NRAblog.com

USA -(Ammoland.com)- September 18 marked 70 years since the official founding of the U.S. Air Force. While the military had purchased its first aircraft in 1909, a mere six years after the Wright Brothers’ milestone successful flight at Kitty Hawk, it wasn’t until after the U.S. Army had sent thousands of Airmen and aircrafts into battle in two World Wars that President Harry Truman, seeing the undeniable significance of airpower in fighting and winning, signed the National Security Act, establishing the Air Force as an independent branch of the U.S. Armed Forces.

A U.S. Air Force Airman armed with an M4 carbine guarding an aircraft. (Photo courtesy/U.S. Air Force)

In the annals of the Air Force’s history, from its Army Air Corps roots to the agile sentry and defender of air, space, and cyberspace it is today, many names conjure the spirit of the service’s beginnings, development and success in the skies and beyond. Airmen look back with deference at Gen. Henry “Hap” Arnold, Brig. Gen. Billy Mitchell, Airman 1st Class William Pitsenbarger, The Tuskegee Airmen, Airman 1st Class (later Sgt.) John Levitow, Brig. Gen. Chuck Yeager, and countless others who epitomize the Air Force’s core values: Integrity First, Service Before Self, and Excellence In All We Do.

In the long list of Airmen who’ve made significant contributions to the Air Force, the military, and the nation’s wars, you’ll find an entry for Gen. Curtis LeMay, the fifth Chief of Staff of the Air Force. General LeMay is best known as the architect of strategic airpower, a fiery and controversial leader who insisted upon the use of nuclear weapons in times of absolute military necessity. In fact, it was LeMay who relayed the Presidential order to drop nuclear bombs on Japan in the final days of World War II and suggested similar firepower years later against North Vietnam in the Vietnam War.

Gen. Curtis LeMay. (Photo courtesy/Real Clear Defense)

However, military history buffs and firearms enthusiasts can also point to another hallmark in LeMay’s long career: he’s the man responsible for bringing the AR-15 rifle to the U.S. military, which would go on to inspire the M16 rifle and change the face of military arms forever.

The AR-15, designed by engineer Eugene Stoner of ArmaLite, a division of California-based Fairchild Engine and Airplane Corporation, was a scaled-down version of Stoner’s initial AR-10, which used the larger 7.62×51 NATO (.308) cartridge. In the late 1950s, Stoner and ArmaLite executive George Sullivan submitted the .22-caliber AR-15 for rifle trials by the U.S. Army Infantry Board after impressing Army Gen. William Wyman.

Though the U.S. military had just adopted the M14 rifle as a replacement to the aging M1 Garands, Wyman’s curiosity was piqued, and he ordered 10 AR-15s and 100,000 rounds of ammo for testing in 1958. Despite mostly positive tests at Fort Benning, where the AR-15 proved to be almost three times as reliable as the M14 during development, Dr. Frederick Carten, an Army Ordnance Corps expert who was opposed to just about everything the AR-15 represented, failed to give the AR-15 a flattering review in his report, and the Ordnance Corps turned away from the innovative rifle. In February 1959, arms maker Colt bought the rights to the AR-15 and AR-10 from ArmaLite for $75,000 plus royalties on future production.

Early AR-15s. (Photo courtesy/Gun Digest)

Enter General LeMay. As the famous story goes, the general was attending a Fourth of July celebration in 1960, and was approached by a salesman from Colt, looking to reintroduce the AR-15 as a viable service rifle. The salesman placed two watermelons on a shooting range – one at 50 and one 150 yards (LeMay colorfully opted to eat a third watermelon) – and handed an AR-15 and loaded magazines to LeMay. The general shot the rifle, and was instantly sold – he placed an order for 80,000 AR-15 rifles on the spot for the U.S. Air Force.

However, Congress stepped in and put the order on hold, citing the Army Ordnance Board’s denial of a re-trial of the improved AR-15 by new owner Colt. When a request came into the Pentagon from Lackland Air Force Base to replace the old M2 carbines with AR-15s, Congress investigated the Ordnance Corps’ refusal to re-evaluate the rifle.

LeMay shooting trap. (Photo courtesy/Smith & Wesson Forum)

As a result, the Ordnance Corps agreed to a new series of tests, completed in November of 1960. After firing nearly 25,000 rounds through three AR-15s, the results were favorable, performing well even in dust, extreme cold, rain and without lubrication. One rifle even produced a 10-round, 1.5-inch group at 100 yards, well within the six-inch requirement. The AR-15 outperformed the M14 and was approved for Air Force trials.

Even then, General LeMay had to apply three times before getting approval to order the rifles for the Air Force. His first attempt, an order of 8,500 rifles initially approved by the Deputy Defense Secretary, was shot down by Congress. The headstrong general took his case directly to President John F. Kennedy, who also failed to approve the order. It wasn’t until May 1962 that LeMay’s order was approved, and with tensions escalating in Southeast Asia, the military found the opportunity to put the new rifle to the test.

LeMay (front right) with President John F. Kennedy. (Photo courtesy/JFK Memorial Library)

AR-15s were used in Vietnam, a move outside the normal procurement process. Reviews from users were favorable, with many preferring the AR-15 to all other service firearms. Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara signed off on a purchase of 1,000 AR-15s in December 1961, and the rifle continued testing among South Vietnamese personnel during Project AGILE. The results were similarly enthusiastic.

However, the Ordnance Corps wasn’t done battling the adoption of the AR-15, reportedly rigging the Arctic tests of the AR-15 to ensure it failed. When Eugene Stoner got word of the dramatic failures of his creations, he flew to Fort Greeley, Alaska to investigate, and found the rifle seemingly deliberately tampered with to result in failure. After repairing each rifle, the tests resumed, and the rifles performed as designed.

Despite the attempted sabotage of the Arctic tests, General LeMay’s investment in the AR-15 was about to pay off. Secretary McNamara was also a fan of the AR-15 and identified the Ordnance Corps reluctance to perform fair tests and recommend adoption. In response, he stopped all new procurements of the M14 rifle and the following year, ordered the Corps to work with every branch of the military to adopt the AR-15 rifle as the standard service rifle of the entire U.S. military. The M16 was born.

U.S. Soldier using M16 in Vietnam. (Photo courtesy/VietnamWarEra.com)

After some improvements were made following initial feedback from circulation, Colt received a $13.5 million contract in November 1963 for 104,000 rifles – 19,000 of which were destined for the U.S. Air Force, where they’d be used predominantly by the Airmen of the Air Force’s Air Police, later known as the USAF Security Police and now designated as Security Forces.

The M16 would go on to face initial problems, particularly due to the change to Ball powder and the impact it had in fouling chambers and causing malfunctions, but changes to the cyclic rate and addition of chrome-lining on barrels and chambers helped alleviate these issues.

U.S. Air Force Security Forces Airman armed with an M4 carbine guarding a B-2 Spirit stealth bomber. (Photo courtesy/American Shooting Journal)

More than 50 years later, the M16 remains in service in the U.S. military in one iteration or another, with Airmen carrying the M4 carbine, a familial successor to the M16, on installations and in combat around the world. With so much of the Air Force’s greatest achievements and contributions to combat superiority taking place in the skies, it’s easy to overlook how an Air Force general pushed for what became an American firearm icon that was adopted by the entire military and beloved as America’s favorite rifle in its commercial variants.

Then again, that’s as much a part of what the Air Force does as the conquering of the wild blue yonder. Airmen have abandoned convention and adopted technology, bucked trends and developed new ways to maintain our combat edge, and used their uncanny ingenuity to help America aim higher. Whether it’s the jaw-dropping agility, stealth, and power of the F-22 Raptor, or something that seems as familiar and simple as the trusty AR-15 rifle, the Air Force and its Airmen have and will continue to push the boundaries as they fly, fight and win.

12 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Zack
Zack
4 years ago

I cheered when that S O B died. It was my missfortune to have been in LeMays SAC at Altus OK, took me 18 months of
using AF Regs to transfer to ATC
Retired June 1973

rwf
rwf
4 years ago

TRhe m16 should never have been allowed into field until the jamming issue was resolved. Such poor mamagement cost the lives of way to many in the Nam… and did not have to happen.. there is NO excuse and article simply down plays as nearly nonexistant how serious jamming was, and how often.. someone needs to tell the truth as story did not. Even at range we were advised “That thing will jam and hang up half the time..etc” Even issued us cleaning rods “to clear gun when jammed”, How odd no one ever paid for all the lives lost… Read more »

topper
topper
4 years ago

To reply to Doc W’s comments: Eugene Stoner designed the AR to function reliably with Remington Ammo (DuPont extruded powder). The Air Force used this ammo whereas the Army and Marines used Olin (Winchester) Ball Powder that produced a much higher incidence of failures to function. The Ordnance Department was against this rifle from the get go and knew that the ball powder’s burn rate was a major factor in its unreliability. It wasn’t their (Ordnance Department’s) design and they did try to sabotage it during testing. The article above makes reference to that.

Jim Carmichel
Jim Carmichel
4 years ago

LeMay was quite a shooter himself. I have a photo of him and me, and a few others shooting prairie dogs in Kansas back in the ’70’s. And as to the photo of him shooting “Trap” look closely and you’ll see he is actually shooting skeet.

Barry Boyce
Barry Boyce
4 years ago

Does anyone know how Air Vice Marshall Earl Godfrey help with the history of the M16?

Michael Bruner
Michael Bruner
4 years ago

Covair in Fort Worth produced the B-58 for several years in the ’60’s. I can still remember them breaking the sound barrier regularly. Later on and all separately, I met five men that piloted the Hustler. They had some great stories about that fabulous plane!! Way ahead of its time, and a maintenance nightmare! My all-time favorite!

Doc W
Doc W
4 years ago

Howdy: While this article lauds LeMay for bring in the black rifle; I curse LeMays name and hope he has an extremely warn place in the depths of hell for two reasons! Remembering back to 1968 to ’70, of all of the dead Marines on hillsides and fields in Viet Nam, found dead with the rifles partially field stripped before them trying to find out why the f**king thing did not work, would not extract, failed to fully feed, rusted all to hell from chamber to muzzle. Platoons and companies worth of dead Marines and soldiers because the god forsaken… Read more »

Pete
Pete
4 years ago

My recollection is that LeMay wanted the AR in 5.56 for plane guards, not as a combat weapon.

Dave Herbert
Dave Herbert
4 years ago

Gen. Le May’s favorite airplane was a Delta wing Fighter Bomber called the B-58 Hustler, which never made it into production. Shame. The powers that be struck again. USAF 61-65 40 mos Atlas D&E Fuels.

TMBJAK
TMBJAK
4 years ago
Reply to  Dave Herbert

Beg to differ…the B-58 was produced for the AF. It served from 1960 to 1970….it was finally replaced w/ the FB-111 Aardvark….
Mike Johnson USAF ret.

J. McLaughlin
J. McLaughlin
4 years ago

LeMay is also to be credited with moving from AM radios to SSB (Single sideband) radios. This greatly improved radio communication. Need more engineer types in officer core and in congress.

JoeUSooner
JoeUSooner
4 years ago
Reply to  J. McLaughlin

PARTICULARLY in Congress