Sig 9mm and Knife Used to Stop Bear Attack in Rural WI Home

Black Bear iStock-482557323
Sig 9mm and Knife used to Stop Bear Attack on Couple in Rural WI Home IMG iStock-482557323

U.S.A.-(AmmoLand.com)-– A little before 11 p.m. on Friday, May 20, a wife and mother looked outside her rural home on Castle rd. near Medford, Wisconsin, in Taylor County. A bear was eating the bird feed from their bird feeder. She partly opened a window and yelled at the bear to go away. The bear disputed her position as owner.  From wqow.com:

According to the Taylor County Sheriff’s Office, authorities received a report of a bear attack at a home on Castle Road in the Township of Medford Friday around 11 p.m.

In a press release, authorities report a husband and wife noticed the bear eating from their bird feeder, opened the window and yelled at the bear to scare it off. The bear then turned and charged at the home, breaking through the window and began attacking the couple, while their kids were asleep in their bedrooms.

Castle road near Medford, Wisconsin, is a mixed landscape of farm fields and pastures with about half forest and a smattering of small lakes and ponds. It is typical of north-central Wisconsin.

This correspondent was able to talk with Larry Woebbeking, Sheriff of Taylor County.  While Sheriff Woebbeking was not at the scene of the attack, he had talked to an investigating officer who was. Larry had interesting information to add. He was sure of his facts.

The bottom of the window was about three to four feet above the ground. The bear had to jump up to get through the window. The window appears to be a typical northern Wisconsin type which slides vertically up and down, with an insect screen on the outside. The screen is gone on the picture from the sheriffs office, so the bear probably clawed the screen out as it came inside.

After the wife yelled at the bear, the bear forced its way through the window and attacked the wife. The husband came to the aid of his wife, interjecting his body between them. The bear attacked him. He suffered severe bites to the neck and may have had an arm broken.

The wife, freed from the bear attack, accessed a knife and attacked the bear mauling her husband. The bear turned its attention back to the wife, which allowed the husband to escape momentarily. He was able to access a 9mm Sig handgun. He quickly returned and killed the bear.

During the attack, which probably lasted 30 seconds, the couple’s children were sleeping in their bedrooms.

It is believed a cub ran into the forest when the sow unprovoked attacked the wife and mother in her own home.

Contrary to common mythology, black bears almost never attack people because of the presence of a cub or cubs. Famed bear researcher, Steven Herrero reported in “Bear Attacks their Causes and Avoidance”, p. 96:

“Researchers studying black bears confirm that black bear females are seldom aggressive, even when harassed.  Al Erickson, who made the pioneer study of black bears in North America, captured 96 bears 109 times in the late 1950’s and early 1960’s.  He stated, contrary to popular belief at the time:

“Most female bears did not display strong maternal protective instinct and quickly abandoned cubs when danger was imminent. In only three of ten cases was the  female  detected in the vicinity of  where cubs of the year had been captured. Two of those mothers attempted to drive off the handling crew by rushing forward, snorting, and rapidly chomping their teeth.  At no time did they approach closer than ten feet.  A particularly aggressive charge could be terminated by making a great deal of noise, particulary loud shouting, which seemed to unnerve the animal.”

Herrero reinforced that data with this statement on the same page:

“El Harger, a Michigan wildlife biologist who studied black bears after Erickson, reported that in trapping and handling more than three hundred bears, only four times did females run them off while they were removing cubs from live traps.”

The presence of cubs should never be considered an appropriate excuse for black bear sows to attack people. Bear apologists often offer this mythology to justify bear attacks on innocent people.

While a knife was used to good effect in this defense against a bear, the 9mm Sig pistol was used to end the attack decisively.


About Dean Weingarten:

Dean Weingarten has been a peace officer, a military officer, was on the University of Wisconsin Pistol Team for four years, and was first certified to teach firearms safety in 1973. He taught the Arizona concealed carry course for fifteen years until the goal of Constitutional Carry was attained. He has degrees in meteorology and mining engineering, and retired from the Department of Defense after a 30 year career in Army Research, Development, Testing, and Evaluation.

Dean Weingarten

4.5 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
10 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Deconflictor

Mr. Weingarten, I always look forward to your human-bear conflict pieces. While Herrero is widely known, I would encourage you to refer to James “Gary” Shelton’s work, “Bear Encounter Survival Guide,” as well as his other books on bear attacks, as a prime source of information on bear behavior and bear defense. Mr. Shelton lived and worked in Bella Coola, BC, from 1964 until shortly before his death three years ago. A hunter, trapper, and guide, as well as a self-taught biologist, geologist, and archologist, he successfully debated Mr. Herrero several times based on his intimate observed knowledge of living… Read more »

StLPro2A

Most of my neighbors are nice, non-aggressive, non-threatening types. But, there is this one sow with cubs……. 🙂 🙂 🙂

The Crimson Pirate

Teamwork makes the dream work

Rowboat

You got you good, law abiding bears and you got your thug bears, just like humans- and should be dealt with similarly.

Matt in Oklahoma

Bird feeders at ground level in bear country ….

john

Waiting approval on a bear comment
How overbearing

john

The fact is that even the most knowledgeable person on bears can not predict what a bear will do and always get it right. A hungry female bear with cubs , advisable to stay clear, A 400 lb black bear is more than 10 times stronger than any man while being able to run at 40 miles per hour and climb faster than any human.
When encountered enjoy they are a wonderful while doing what bears do.

Duane

It has been my experience hunting bears with hounds for 30 plus years.

That black bear sows quickly abandoned their cubs. Leaving them in a tree while they ran off.

I had several bears around the house most leave quickly. But one never knows.

JPM

I have seen first hand sows abandon their cubs while the cubs climb trees, but back in 1984, there was a bunch of black bear attacks in the panhandle of Idaho. I was working there at the time and we had 2 people put up trees by sows with cubs, one who was “treed” for 3 hours before the sow and cubs left. That same summer, there were 3 people attacked and injured by black bears in the forest and a dozen or more reported encounters with black bears running away from hikers and campers and not attacking. Unpredictable is… Read more »