Michael Moore’s Proposed 2nd Amendment Repeal: As Impossible As It Is Evil

Michael Moore’s Proposed 2nd Amendment Repeal IMG NRA
Michael Moore’s Proposed 2nd Amendment Repeal IMG NRA

U.S.A. – -(Ammoland.com)- “THE 28th AMENDMENT: My proposal to repeal and replace the 2nd Amendment,” the new propaganda “documentarian” Michael Moore offers on his website. In essence, he’s presuming himself to be wiser and more educated than the Founders and goes about “proving” it by replacing one sentence with eight sections of convoluted prohibitions designed to usher in a totalitarian monopoly of violence.

That becomes a moot point when one side controls all the guns. The words will mean what the rulers say they mean.

Let’s start with Section 1. It’s the only one I will address in detail because it demonstrates right out of the starting gate how ignorant Moore’s understanding of the Constitution is.

“The inalienable right of a free people to be kept safe from gun violence and the fear thereof must not be infringed and shall be protected by the Congress and the States,” Moore bloviates. “This Amendment thus repeals and replaces the Second Amendment.”

Unalienable (that’s the word used in the Declaration) rights are not created and then bestowed by the government. When it comes to the Second Amendment, the Supreme Court has recognized and reconfirmed this in the Heller case:

“This is not a right granted by the Constitution. Neither is it in any manner dependent upon that instrument for its existence.”

(As an aside, having a “right … to be kept safe” implies a duty to protect on the part of someone else, that is, a demand on third parties to put their life on the line to save yours, with penalties should they fail. As for a right not to fear, does it get any more subjective, especially with the prohibitionists doing everything they can to spook the herd every chance they get?)

Going back to what SCOTUS acknowledged, if you could “repeal the Second Amendment,” that would still not repeal the individual right to keep and bear arms. Just because a tyrant says your rights are rescinded does not make it so, and at that point, it boils down to whether millions of armed victims of state-initiated force or fraud decide to obey or resist those claiming false sovereignty over their rights.

Why NRA hasn’t invoked its bylaws and expelled someone flagrantly and consistently subverting them is for them to say. (Michael Moore/Facebook)

With what Moore demands, that choice is clear.

He wants mandatory annual licensing and registration, prior restraints, waiting periods, undefined “mental health” disqualifiers, “vetting” with the ability of those who don’t want you to have a gun to see you denied, mandatory training and tests, a minimum age of 25, disapproved gun bans, ammunition bans…

Applied to a 100 million + gun owners? Any idea on the resources all this would require?

No worries. He’s got another bright idea that ought to eliminate just about everything and everybody the government doesn’t approve of from having a gun:

“No weapons of any kind whose sole intention is the premeditated elimination of human life are considered legal. Congress may create future restrictions as this amendment specifically does not grant any American the ‘right’ to own any weapon.”

There goes the right to resist tyranny. And remember, Joe Biden shooting his shotgun through a door shows a premeditated attempt to eliminate human life.

Does anybody see a designated power in the Constitution authorizing Congress to “grant” rights? Recall that not just the Constitution but the Bill of Rights came with a Preamble to make clear that the intent was to empower the people and restrain the government:

“THE Conventions of a number of the States, having at the time of their adopting the Constitution, expressed a desire, in order to prevent misconstruction or abuse of its powers, that further declaratory and restrictive clauses should be added: And as extending the ground of public confidence in the Government, will best ensure the beneficent ends of its institution.”

That’s why it’s not called the Bill of Powers.

Moore’s next section is a warning to all you “Only Ones” who will be “just following orders” and enforcing this abomination—say or do anything that can be construed as traditionally American, and it’ll be your turn in the barrel. Hey, if the state doesn’t respect the Second Amendment, why would it worry about honoring the First?

Moore ends his screed with the terms of surrender, basically a mandate to obey or die:

“Persons already owning any of the above banned firearms, and who do not fall into the legal groups of restricted firearms owners, will have one month from the ratification of this Amendment to turn in their firearms for destruction by local law enforcement. These local authorities may organize a gun buy-back program to assist in this effort.”

In the words of Austin Powers’ Dr. Evil, “How about ‘No’?” And again, just as a theoretical and to show how ludicrous what this idiot calls for is, how many tens of millions of gun owners would be caught up in this net, and what kind of impossible resources and timeline would this require?

There’s also the civil precedent established in Printz v. United States that local cops can’t be dragooned into performing federal infringements. Then add to all this what it takes to amend the Constitution. Moore is dreaming out loud for his ridiculous fanboys (check some of these effete imbeciles out in the comments on his site). That and trolling for attention.

This isn’t the first time Moore has called to repeal 2A. And it won’t be the first time I have called on NRA to expel Moore, who claims to be a Life Member (it’s actually the third in the last 20 years — to my knowledge, he has never renounced it and was still publicly claiming membership in 2019). Yet per the Bylaws:

“Any individual or organization member may be suspended or expelled for good cause, including, but not limited to, any conduct which is contrary to, or in violation of the Bylaws of the Association.”

Calling for repeal of the Second Amendment, “a complete gun ban in the U.S.,” and calling NRA a “terrorist organization” certainly seems to violate the “eligibility” requirement to “subscribe to the objectives and purposes of the Association.”

“But wait,” as late TV pitchman Billy Mays used to say, “there’s more!” There always is with megalomaniacal control freaks.

Not satisfied with remaking the Bill of Rights in his own image, earlier this month, Moore “rewrote” the Declaration of Independence to issue “demands,” to “insist” on reparations for blacks, and the removal of “every single Republican from office.” Additionally, he makes the following threat that demonstrates, if nothing else, how the guy thinks the universe revolves around his navel (presuming he can find it):

“Until women’s rights have been fully reinstated, and their equal rights are enshrined in our Constitution (now that the required 38 states have passed the Equal Rights Amendment), I will not shut up about this. If you invite me to dinner that’s all I’m gonna talk about. Have me over to your party and it’s going to be, “Dobbs, Dobbs, and more Dobbs!” And I won’t stop until Roe is reinstated and 51% of Congress is female.”

Well, that’s easy enough to fix. I haven’t been this filled with dread since David Hogg threatened not to have children (for Michael to abort?).

Make no mistake: His totalitarian position, and that’s exactly what it is, is “Surrender and obey or be destroyed.” His sick ego invites civil war and untold deaths unless his demands are met. As long as it’s someone else doing the fighting — no one expects multimillionaire Marxist revolutionaries to lead by example, do they? And so much for the fraudulent “inalienable” nature of his “Section 1” guarantee to keep people “safe from gun violence and the fear thereof.”

The “secret” the would-be controllers don’t want people to realize is that as battered as it is, the Second Amendment still offers the last best hope against tyranny. That’s why there are no general confiscation orders from those who would like nothing better. As much as they want to establish an unchallengeable monopoly of violence, a critical mass of gun owners simply will not disarm. We just won’t.

That triggers their impotent rage and hate because they know that we are armed and everywhere.

About David Codrea:David Codrea
David Codrea is the winner of multiple journalist awards for investigating/defending the RKBA and a long-time gun owner rights advocate who defiantly challenges the folly of citizen disarmament. He blogs at “The War on Guns: Notes from the Resistance,” is a regularly featured contributor to Firearms News, and posts on Twitter: @dcodrea and Facebook.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

A repeal of the US2A would net liberals very few guns. What it would do is get pigs, blue boys and badge pushers shot on sight!


You can find the fat slugs YouTube channel and comment for free.


Does his hat say nra member ?? Figures !


Either of those pictures would be good for target practice !

Last edited 28 days ago by Oldvet

Has this over weight Leftist douche ever come out publically against criminals, thugs, rapists, thieves or terrorists? But he wants to disarm all law abiding people who have firearms? I rest my case.

Our Legacy III

I tried creating an account to comment and they make you pay for your subscription saying it’s to stop trolls!! Lmfao I won’t pay the $5 to add to his bank account. The comments are ridiculous!! People saying hunting shouldn’t even be allowed bc of animal rights. People are ok with raising cattle for meat but not hunting them? Wtf is wrong with the left? These goons need to go. California is already lost to the democrats violence and destruction so let the libtards have the Rockies-west to the pacific. Let’s peacefully separate now before things get ugly. Fat ass… Read more »


Giving this guy band width is worse than giving a mass shooter band width. I see him as a real life version of Jabba the Hut. An oversized brainless whale who better not be on the beach too often for the possibility exists that a real whale may get confused. He is disgusting, and gives a bad name to pigs. His ideas come from a demented mind that takes reality and twists it into demented video.

Why would anyone read anything he has to say? How special does he think he is. A real piece of work.

Our Legacy III

I can’t believe there are people that pay hundreds of dollars a year just to be apart of his communist website. Dude needs to disappear! Take him and his views to China, he’ll fit right in.


What he and those like him don’t seem to understand is the 2nd amendment is there for one reason and only one reason, to protect ourselves from people that have no respect for other’s property or their rights and wish to take them away. Him and people that agree with him are the reason the 2nd exist in the first place.

Capn Dad

He’s and obese slob. You can count on him having a cardiac exit soon enough.


I’ll bet he smells bad too.


We can only hope Maybe he was jabbed…did you read that there is a new heart ailment going around that they can’t figure out what is causing it? Like DUH?


This 2 legged turd, the whoopie creature, mad maxine and the Abrams M1A2 could form the most amazing carnival sideshow in history! Can you imagine this blob and M1A2 in competition at a smorgasbord?!


I don’t know which is more repugnant, this foul conglomeration of protoplasm or it’s ideas.


He has a gun! Red flag him!


Without getting excited or so much as raising my voice, I would tell Moore and others, proposing this, to perform a physically impossible sex act on themselves.


Maybe should walk alone on his favorite cities. NYC, LA, Chicago, St. Louis, San Diego or ride any subway.
No police or bodyguards allowed.


In his case, I bet it isn’t impossible. I’d tell him to come personally to enforce his new “amendment”. Because I’d love to shoot him in the face.


This whatever it is (Michael Moore) is the closest thing to a liberal dictator I have ever seen. He thinks he knows everything about everything. He should be put in his place, which is not in America IMHO…


deport him to china, or better yet North Korea he wants to be a slave that is the place for him , bet they dont let him keep the camera or open his mouth

Dogma Factor

As Mr. Moore is so disillusioned with American values perhaps he should extricate himself from this country. I’d recommend Cuba as it’s the closest communist state which would be more inline with his personal values. I’m sure he’ll have a wonderful time there as a political prisoner after his first public tantrum.


Blaming guns for violence is like blaming the knife and fork for obesity. Like all progressive tyrants Mr. Moore wants to blame inanimate objects for the actions of people. People like Moore may have a genetic predisposition for obesity, but his use of eating utensils probably exasperated his condition. However, his rants and raves against freedom and America is only the result of his addled brain and lack of logic. He is a huckster, trying to make his living through buffoonery and grifting. He is a con artist and fat slob.


““No weapons of any kind whose sole intention is the premeditated elimination of human life are considered legal. Congress may create future restrictions as this amendment specifically does not grant any American the ‘right’ to own any weapon.”” Ever heard of a weapon whose sole intention is the elimination of human life?


Michael Moore is a moron.
Always has been.
Can’t make a decent film.
In general is a worthless human being.
One of my friends walked off a project because he was disgusting. Best decision she ever made. She is a good conservative woman.
He should have been swallowed at birth.
Disgusting person.
People like him should have there citizenship revoked and punted out of this country.
That goes for all the people that don’t follow the constitution. One way ticket to China.

Last edited 29 days ago by Bubba
Mystic Wolf

Why can’t some stick him with a needle full,of cobra venom or something, mikey moore is a worthless person, hecwould not even make a good target, he would however make good as Jabba da Hutt


Moore is such a fan of abortion. It is a shame his mother did not make that choice.


argument for late term abortion


Years ago there a cartoon of a prisoner being dragged off to the electric chair. The caption was: “The Supreme Court says it is ok, we are calling a delayed abortion.”


Perhaps this rotund moron should read up on some 20th Century history and find out what happened to the people living in those countries whose authoritarian governments decided to disarm their civilian populations. Take a look at what happened in the Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, Red China, Cambodia, Vietnam, Cuba, and the list goes on. The price these civilians paid: well more than 100 million innocent people murdered by their own governments. No thanks, moron, I’ll keep my Second Amendment. If you are so afraid of your fellow citizens, go hide under your bed; the lessons of history are that… Read more »


F*cking Buffoon!


Baffons are not happy with being compared to THAT!


Forget it FAT ASS this is not Canada . How about the first amendment fat boy ? Time for you to shut up and go home to Canada where your communist leader shares your anti American views ! Communist prick .




Forget for a moment who’s proposing this – nearly all readers will have the same opinion of him. And forget for a moment that this is about the 2nd Amendment. This is a proposal – which has come from others in the past – to repeal a portion of the Bill of Rights. If ANY portion of the Bill of Rights is ever repealed, then precedent would be established to abolish the ENTIRE Bill of RIghts. In my not so humble opinion, THAT is the ultimate endgame of the people who hate this country.

Mystic Wolf

The satan worshipping DEMONcrats already have a new Constitution already written up and ready to put in place, they are just waiting for the convention of the states so they can put the new constitution in place and forever take all our rights away from us making the people slaves to the Government. Welcome to 1984, your worst nightmare will soon come to life.


RIGHTS can only be INFRINGED upon. They cannot be TAKEN AWAY!

Our Legacy III

Demoncrats… I haven’t heard that one before… STEALING IT!!! Thanks!! My go to’s are CommieCrats, DemoCommies, and Libtards. I can’t wait to post this new one on some Commies page on Twitter!!


Do understand that these people will not stop with The Bill of Rights. Their end game is to abolish The Constitution itself; in point of fact, for those who have not noticed, the Left has been shredding The Constitution, one little piece at a time, for well more than a century.


My rights are not written on a piece of paper. 350 million people could vote to do away with the bill of rights and all it would do is nothing in reality. Rights are UNALIENABLE as Jefferson said in the DOI. That means the only way the go away is by DEATH.


ESAD Michael Moore. I counter with this:

The rights of the people, irrespective of sex, ethnicity, or any age greater than the age to vote, to keep, carry, use, purchase, sell, transfer, import, transport, innovate on, communicate about, or to manufacture arms, their accessories, components, and munitions shall not be restrained by prejudice or by law, by regulation, by treaty, by extraordinary tax, by fee, by tariff, by executive order, by history, nor by any other contrivance or treachery by Federal, Territory, Protectorate, District, State or Commonwealth governments or any subdivision thereof.

Last edited 29 days ago by DIYinSTL

Sounds like a proper definition for SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED!


Wasted words on a waste of life
Moore has never been nothing more than a mouth a media moment that expires same day.


Taking guns out of the hands of felons and “gang-bangers is really working out well isn’t it Mikey? Leave legal gun owners alone.


I’d like it if he’d fill the old sodomobile ( or whatever the pink Winnebago he had was called) up with as many of his friends as he could find and head right back to Canada. I doubt they would let him back in though. Finally rid of the fat old woman.,


Funny you should say that. I worked with a lesbian from Canada who soty of reminds me of him.


Dream on fat boy

Miserable Wretch

I’d wish ill on him, but I won’t. His eating habits will cause him to die of heart failure by the time he reaches 75.

Deplorable Bill

In the mid 1930’s Hitler registered firearms “For a kinder, gentler nation” and the world lived haply ever after right? The right, the command to keep and bear arms comes directly from the LORD see Luke 22:36. In America, this right is written into law as the 2A. Thus, anyone saying or doing or proclaiming otherwise or against this right is either evil or treasonous or both. I am Christian and I will live and die for the WORD of GOD. I am American and I have put my life on the line in defense of the rights and freedoms… Read more »


Great comment. You’re not alone !


so far no one has come close to walking on water , or saving someone beyond medical help so , yea they would need 100s of bags if they tried a red flag on me


Most of this was not done on this continent. MOST? Were we subject to an armed invasion at some point and I didn’t realize it?

Deplorable Bill

East side of South America, Panama, Salvador etc. Can’t seem to recall dates and times etc.

Arm up and carry on

Our Legacy III

I am with you as He is with us!! God bless America!!


Does anybody really believe that a piece of paper will make guns go away? Or that firearms are in this world ONLY by permission of lawmakers, liberals and cop ticket pushers?

Green Mtn. Boy

The talking Turd speaks.


His name should by spelled MORON


I sure thought that tick bit slob died a few months back !


Couldn’t be so lucky.


“tick bit slob” ~ Ope (Will/Tex)

Maybe he ate too many donuts:

comment image


-3: good morning, Will!

Patriot Solutions

The slob reminds me of the [Snowflake Club] sign with the pentagram in it’s logo mounted on the city of Woodland Parks city sign along hwy 24 in Teller County Cabalarado that can be seen driving into town from the east.


I wonder what he would think if President Trump wrote the same thing but reversed it all. No ban on any guns, all demoncrats removed from office, everyone including felons have the right to have firearms. All movie industry, music industry news industry that are demoncrap cannot have any guns ever.

On and on down his list putting him in the position we would want. You know we would never hear the end of it from the mass media and our non elected stolen election liar and thief.

FMM and uncle joe kamala toe.


uncle dudley

Why would anyone listen to this clowns advice.


He should move to Cuba.


He should go swimming around a Japanese whaling fleet and see what happens.


He should move to some undisclosed location about six feet under in Obese Fatass Hill Cemetery.


North Korea , im sure he would fit right in and slim down


Kim would eat him…or would it be the other way around… Oh that’s right, Kim has the guns… Nevermind. Haha