The Privilege of Misconstruing Data

Shannon Watts
Ms. Shannon Watts happily throws a false claim of CDC data at a woman who wants only to protect her child from a very real threat.
National Rifle Association Institute For Legislative Action (NRA-ILA)
National Rifle Association Institute For Legislative Action (NRA-ILA)

Fairfax, VA – -(Ammoland.com)-  Earlier this month, the head of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America (Shannon Watts, not benefactor Michael Bloomberg) brutally dismissed an op-ed in the New York Times by Bethany Mandel as an anecdote of fear and paranoia. 

The anecdote? As a young girl, a home intruder climbing through her bedroom window threatened Mandel.

Her mother used a firearm to defend her. More recently, Mandel routinely received death threats for her political commentary and was doxxed by neo-Nazis – which led her to obtain a firearms permit in her home state of New Jersey. In other words, Ms. Mandel was literally saved by a firearm as a child and obtained a firearms permit to protect herself and her own child after neo-Nazis published her home address.

Ms. Watts chalked Ms. Mandel’s efforts to protect herself from the very real threats as privilege:

 

Racist Shannon Watts
Racist Shannon Watts

Watts seems to be referencing CDC data from a 1993 study led by Arthur Kellerman that concludes, “Rather than confer protection, guns kept in the home are associated with an increase in the risk of homicide by a family member or intimate acquaintance.”

This study focused on different time periods in three counties in three different states, none of which is as diverse as the country itself. Researchers canvassed the neighborhoods of murder victims in these counties to find someone who roughly matched the victim’s demographic profile (age, sex, and race) to use as a control and interviewed relatives of the actual murder victims. 

Methodological concerns include biases, ignorance of relatives’ criminal behavior, coverage issues, and even the possibility that canvassers may have avoided going to certain houses if they felt uneasy or frightened. Often overlooked is the finding is that renting and living alone provide the second highest odds of being murdered (illicit drug use is first).  

Perhaps the most glaring issue is that only cases that resulted in a fatality were included. Non-fatal defensive gun uses were by intent excluded. Noted criminologists Gary Kleck and Marc Gertz found in their 1995 study Armed Resistance to Crime: The Prevalence and Nature of Self-Defense with a Gun that only about 4.5% of defensive gun uses involved the defender firing a weapon at a perpetrator (note: this is not the number of defensive gun uses that resulted in a fatality). In total, only 24% of defensive gun uses involved shots fired – meaning Kellerman et al. focused on a minority of all defensive gun uses. Kleck validates this estimate by noting that the National Crime Victimization Survey found that 17% of gun crimes involve the offender shooting the victim.

But Ms. Watts happily throws a false claim of CDC data at a woman who wants only to protect her child from a very real threat.

If Ms. Watts really wanted to use the Kellerman study to guide Ms. Mandel’s choices regarding her safety, she should urge Mandel to neither rent nor live alone – both of which are, according to the flawed Kellerman study that Watts relies upon, substantially more dangerous than keeping a firearm in the home.

About:
Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the “lobbying” arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Visit: www.nra.org

Subscribe
Notify of
9 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
No Bull
No Bull
2 years ago

And now our friends in the swamp have opened up the gates to allow the cdc to continue its attack on the 2nd. They used false premises to create false data the first time. Got shut down. And now they are handed the power back. Thanks rebulicans! I suppose if you really supported the 2nd we’d have nothing to bitch about except illegal immigration, taxes and welfare.

Missouri Born
Missouri Born
2 years ago

Women are the ones who raise the kids and if the kid uses a gun to shoot or kill someone who is at fault.
The kid, the gun, or the woman who raised them?
I wonder if moms demand action have thought about that!

PowderKeg
PowderKeg
2 years ago

Without a Gun Narrative…..you would be boring!

RetSgt
RetSgt
2 years ago

The Golden Poison Frog is kinda cute….

Lou
Lou
2 years ago

She may wrong, but she is kinda cute.

Jim Macklin
Jim Macklin
2 years ago
Reply to  Lou

You need to see a qualified optometrist.

tomcat
tomcat
2 years ago
Reply to  Jim Macklin

Macklin, that’s exactly what I was thinking. That could be Mack stamped backwards on her forehead.

Heart of TEXAS
Heart of TEXAS
2 years ago
Reply to  Lou

Your sense of taste is all in your mouth.

Bill
Bill
2 years ago
Reply to  Lou

Some beauty is only skin deep. Intelligence, honesty, and goodness of heart have much nicer beauty.