Palmetto State Armory AR-15 Build Review

Palmetto State Armory Rifle
The rifle that I built while visiting Palmetto State Armory.

U.S.A.-(Ammoland.com)- Not too long ago Ammoland Editor Duncan Johnson and I went to visit Palmetto State Armory's numerous facilities. If you haven't read the two posts about our visit, make sure to read both Part 1 as well as Part 2. As a part of our tour, we were allowed to build our very own Palmetto State Armory AR-15 in their assembly facility under the watchful eye of PSA's top engineer.

What made me use some of the parts that I did? I had to use what was available, what was going to work with the 16″ Stainless Freedom barrel, and what I like on a rifle. I also went with a slightly unconventional optic setup because frankly, I wanted to try it out.

Optics

Let's get the optics out of the way first, shall we? I selected a Vortex Strike Eagle 1-6 scope since I am rather familiar with the optic. I have one in a Warne mount just like this one on a beater rifle that I often reconfigure for reviews and another on the Ruger Gunsite Scout that I wrote about in my quest for the perfect truck gun as well as the review of the Gunsite Scout.

While it isn't the optimal scope, it is cheap and effective. Zeroing the rifle is easy, it has an illuminated reticle, and magnification adjustments are easy. The easy to use BDC made shots out to 400 yards easy but spotting impacts was hard at times. The glass isn't as clear as I would prefer and the reticle, while easy to acquire, is rather large and can cover an impact at longer ranges.

The Vortex Strike Eagle 1-6 in a Warne 30mm mount was ideal for the 16″ build.

Where things got a bit untraditional is the addition of a Trijicon RMR RM 06 on a Magpul 45-degree M-Lok mount. This isn't the most ideal setup for a 45-degree red dot, but it was what the Palmetto State Armory store had in stock at the time. While I didn't really have a need to transition from magnified optics to a red dot quickly, I really wanted to see if those weird 3 gun guys are onto something.

While it was much faster to transition from near targets to further ones, I will say that I found the additional sight overkill for recreational shooting. I kind of expected that outcome and have since relocated the Trijicon RMR to a pistol, but I am really glad that I tried it out. Should I start shooting two or three gun, the dual optics setup would absolutely be worth revisiting.

A 45-degree mounted RMR was worth a try even if it was overkill for recreational shooting.

Upper Receiver

As I said earlier, the 16″ stainless steel Freedom barrel was the one factor that I didn't choose myself. While we were at DC Machine, those were the barrels that were just coming off the line and Josiah wanted us to see how our barrels were made. I am entirely happy with the 16″ stainless option since it checks all the boxes, a midlength gas system, 1:7 twist rate, and chambered in 5.56 NATO.

We used a 16″ stainless steel Freedom barrel with a 1:7 twist rate.

The flash hider is an A2 like PSA uses on just about all of their uppers and rifles. While I might have gone with a brake, the A2 is functional and few other muzzle devices do as good of a job suppressing flash for as cheap as the A2 is.

As with just about all their rifles, this one also wears an A2 flash hider.

The handguard choice was easy, both Duncan and I chose the 15″ lightweight M-LOK rail. The rail has a pic rail to accommodate BUIS as well as a small section just forward of the upper receiver.

We fitted the 15″ PSA Lightweight M-Lok handguard.

I found the barrel nut design rather interesting. My go-to rail normally a Geissele MK8 13″ or 15″ depending on barrel length. One of the things I really love about the Geissele rail is the barrel nut, which is very similar to the PSA barrel nut.

Not only do I really like rails that secure with a pinch method, installing the barrel nut is super easy since you don't need to time it to the gas tube. Sure, there are other benifits, but there is still a ton to cover.

The barrel nut has wrench flats for easy install and is very similar to other pinch style handguards.

We used a forged upper receiver that was milled in the DC Machine shop just like the barrel. As a part of their assembly process, PSA fits the forward assist and dust cover before it makes it to the assembly tables.

The charging handle is a standard mil-spec unit, while functional it isn't my first choice and will likely be replaced at some point with a BCM Gunfighter handle or a Radian Weapon Systems Raptor.

I am rather impressed by Palmetto's Premium full-auto bolt carrier group. The staking on the gas key was done well, the machine work is on par with more expensive BCGs that are twice what you can get one for normally, it has a Carpenter 158 bolt that has been HPT/MPI tested, chrome lined carrier and gas key, and even uses the correct grade 8 bolts.

A standard charging handle wasn't my first choice, but it works. We also used a premium full-auto profile BCG.

As I just mentioned, the bolt is made from the correct steel for a mil-spec bolt, Carpenter 158. PSA also shot peens the bolt, has it mag particle inspected, and high pressure tested.

The Premium Full-Auto BCG is one of the better quality units for less than $150.

Digging into the bolt a bit further we find a black insert extractor spring and a black o-ring to help with extraction.

PSA uses an o-ring and a black insert extractor spring.

Lower Receiver

We started with a standard stripped Palmetto State Armory lower and a lower parts kits minus the trigger. I chose to go with a MIAD 1.1 grip since that is what is on most of my rifles and I really like the ability to use the slim panels without the A2 finger groove. The oil bottle in the grip is also nice to have at the range since I almost always forget to replace the oil in my range bag.

Just about every AR I own has a MIAD 1.1 installed, another favorite of mine.

The reason I went with the lower parts kit without the trigger group is so that I could use the excellent nickel boron two stage trigger Palmetto State Armory. With the first stage weight being 1 3/4 pound and the second stage being the same, total trigger pull weight is 3.5 pounds.

Reset is nice and positive, and while there is a touch of creep as the trigger breaks it is well beyond my expectations for a trigger that routinely sell for right at $100.

We used the PSA 2 Stage nickel boron trigger.

Since commercial receiver extensions are the work of the devil, we fitted a mil-spec tube made by PSA. I used a standard end plate and castle nut since those are perfectly adequate for my needs, I never use any of the endplate QD sockets on any of my other rifles.

The stock is an old favorite of mine, the Magpul CTR. A really like the simple, no-nonsense design and the lock makes it feel a lot more substantial than many other stocks on the market. The CTR has been one of my go-to stocks since its introduction and will likely continue to be a favorite of mine.

Magpul's CTR stock is one of my go-to stock options.

Another thing that I do to all of my rifles is a Magpul MOE trigger guard or something similar. Since PSA has MOE trigger guards by the box full, there was no reason to not install one on the rifle.

I personally loathe mil-spec trigger guards, the Magpul MOE trigger guard was a no-brainer.

How did it shoot?

While I don't have thousands of rounds through the rifle, I have had a chance to put several brands of ammo through the rifle putting the round count in the 450 to 500 round range. The reality is, I just don't go to a rifle range enough to get the round count up higher to see how my build will hold up in the long run.

The rifle has digested 55-grain, 62-grain, 75-grain, and 77-grain brass case ammo and even a bunch of steel case garbage ammo without a problem. The recoil impulse feels like an AR, but a touch softer than a standard carbine gas system rifle thanks to the mid-length gas tube.

When shooting the rifle for groups with a few types of ammo, I found the IMI Razor Core 77-grain load to shoot the tightest groups at 100-yards. The best I was able to eek out of the rifle using one of the new Magpul bipods and a rear bag was 1.614″. The worst performer was predictably the 62-grain xm855  with a 3.241″ group. If you aren't impressed with 1.53 MOA out of an upper that can be had for under $300, I don't know what to tell you.

My best results of 1.614″ at 100-yards was with IMI Razor Core 77-grain OTM ammo.

Conclusion

I am super happy with how the build turned out, the only thing I have changed about the rifle is I removed the RMR. There just wasn't a need for the second optic on a rifle that is going to almost exclusively be shot from a bench at 100 to 200 yards.

If I end up changing anything else on the rifle, it is going to be the standard mil-spec charging handle and the mil-spec selector. I would probably go with the Radian Raptor and the Talon selector, both are go-to parts and are installed on just about all of my non-clone builds.

While I have no idea what replicating this rifle would run you on the PSA website since the exact configuration isn't listed, I would wager a guess that during this Christmas sale it should be under $500 for the rifle without optics. PSA does have several options that are super close to the rifle I built, just not the exact one.

Learn more about Palmetto State Armory's product lineup on the PSA website and don't forget to check out their Daily Deals section, sometimes it can be hard to not buy one of their deals.


About Patrick R.Patrick Roberts

Patrick is a firearms enthusiast that values the quest for not only the best possible gear setup but also pragmatic ways to improve his shooting skills across a wide range of disciplines. He values truthful, honest information above all else and had committed to cutting through marketing fluff to deliver the truth. You can find the rest of his work on FirearmRack.com as well as on the YouTube channel Firearm Rack or Instagram at @thepatrickroberts.

  • 11 thoughts on “Palmetto State Armory AR-15 Build Review

    1. This company is disgraceful. Absolutely non-existent customer service. I take that back, arrogant and condescending customer service. So I give you my money, you fail to confirm whether you actually mail the package. Then tell me that “if we created a label, then we put the package together”, but refuse to confirm if the package was physically created. UPS had no problem in confirming that they did not receive the package. These guys kept talking around in circles, never admitting that it was possible that they created a label and forgot to put the package together or possibly misplaced it. I STILL HAVE NOT RECEIVED MY PACKAGE OR ANY CONFIRMATION OF ITS STATUS. This company is a POS. Never again. Nancy Pelosi and Dianne Feinstein must be on the Board of Directors.

      1. Maybe. The reality is we are talking about a $300 upper that is shooting as well as uppers that cost two to three times that much 10 years ago with mil-spec ammo.

        I did discover that the bipod attachment nuts were contacting the barrel when it flexed as the bullet was being fired. The slimline handguard isn’t exactly designed to have a bipod loaded up the way I do when shooting for precision. I noticed the same thing on a PSA 6.5 Creed that I am testing right now after the article published.

        But back to my original point, it is a $300 upper, not a match grade, no expense spared upper. I will take 1.53 MOA all day long for $300.

    2. Sounds good to me, I’d like to have one with a .243 cal barrel, to me that would be the ultimate AR I’d call it the AR 18. Hawkeye

    3. There’s Patrick. I wondered where you were. Missed reading your stuff at another place. I like PSA as well. I’ve had good luck so far with everything I’ve bought from them. A tasty little AR9 is on my mind. You can buy some better parts out there for WAY more money. They’ve got the best value going on many things. Watch their sales, blems, and half-builds. It’s surprising what they offer. I’ve not checked in the last few days, but you could get a base AR10 for around $400. Unreal.

      1. I built one of those nasty little ar9s I love it we got the 4 inch barrel and a 80 percent receiver for glock mags it sings

    4. The one thing I took away from this article, besides the recommendations on parts, is the bad accuracy from the XM855 ammo. I bought 1000 rounds of this stuff back about 4 years ago, right before I bought my first AR. My rifle has a Nikon P-223 fixed 3 power scope and I was having a lot of trouble getting any kind of a “good group” at the range. My rifle has a typical 1-8 twist M4 profile barrel and I was blaming that, the stock trigger and the scope for my lousy groups. Thanks for confirming that my suspicions about the XM855 ammo were correct. I had not read anything about accuracy issues with this ammo anywhere else, except that it was “set up” ammo and not regular production.
      I have since bought a 18″ SS 1-7 twist barrel and 15″ handguard along with a Gissele trigger. Hopefully my groups will improve when these parts are finally installed.

      Phil in TX

    5. I just finished a build of a PSA 10.5 INCH pistol. First time ever built an AR even though I have 4. Anyway I used an Aero stripped lower. I removed the AR round handguards and put Magpul 7 inch on it with hardware both sides for add ons and a slant grip. When started build lower I went YouTube and found a video that seemed ok. Had some minor probs but in 30 minutes had mag release, bolt release and pivot pin in and went to bed. Have insomnia so got up at 1am and back to workshop. Finished entire thing hour later. Biggest problem was finding an Allen wrench long enough to screw in bolt inside grip. In desperation found that the tip of a .22 cleaning rod works perfect if u also use a pliers to turn the rod. Everything was there and also have one extra spring and little detent piece. All seems to work perfect.

    6. This review pretty much sums up the typical AR platform build from Palmetto State Arms. If you are planning to build a good AR rifle, go to Palmetto State Arm’s website daily and check their blemished parts for good deals. PSA evidently has some very stringent quality control requirements because you will be surprised at what they call a blemished piece. Even still, their prices on quality bolt carrier groups and triggers cannot be beat.

      1. I echo what Don just said. I’ve been doing business with PSA for a while and their “blemished” parts always amaze me. Bought a blemished upper, went over every square inch of it and couldn’t even find a minor scratch or area when the finish failed to be perfect. My brother then went over it and, like me, couldn’t find anything. I have no idea what they classify as a “blemish”.

        Aside from that their service is first rate. They are one of the few businesses I have no reservations recommending without hesitation.

    Leave a Comment 11 Comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *